DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - @akabirofdeoband & others, regd. Hamza Yusuf, Harun Yahya & Dajjal & TJS George.

**Abnorttrano** · 09-04-2012, 03:57 AM

Knowing what I know about shaykh hamza yusuf-he would be very happy that you are attacking him,
as your attack insha'allah is purely a manifestation of the muhabbah of the blessed prophet(saw),
whose love poems shaykh hamza yusuf has popularised so that young lads who were going on jamaat like me and never knew
anything about love of the Prophet(saw) except the six points, now know to sing the Burdah also(which was inicidentally a desire of Mawlana Ilyas also (rahmatullahi Alayhi)

When Mawlana Tahanwi(ra) heard of the death of imam ahmad rida, he defeneded his attack on him saying he should have done it
as he did it out of perceived love for the Prophet(saw)
He didnt know that Mawlana Tahanwi (ra) was not a bay-adab- but possibly was functioning at a conceptual level not available to imam ahmad rida.
Something similar happens here.

09-04-2012, 03:57 AM	#16
Abnorttrano Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 533 Senior Member	Knowing what I know about shaykh hamza yusuf-he would be very happy that you are attacking him, as your attack insha'allah is purely a manifestation of the muhabbah of the blessed prophet(saw), whose love poems shaykh hamza yusuf has popularised so that young lads who were going on jamaat like me and never knew anything about love of the Prophet(saw) except the six points, now know to sing the Burdah also(which was inicidentally a desire of Mawlana Ilyas also (rahmatullahi Alayhi) When Mawlana Tahanwi(ra) heard of the death of imam ahmad rida, he defeneded his attack on him saying he should have done it as he did it out of perceived love for the Prophet(saw) He didnt know that Mawlana Tahanwi (ra) was not a bay-adab- but possibly was functioning at a conceptual level not available to imam ahmad rida. Something similar happens here.
	Quote