DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - @akabirofdeoband & others, regd. Hamza Yusuf, Harun Yahya & Dajjal & TJS George.

**Svatudjw** · 09-04-2012, 02:57 AM

...And there is no one claiming the works titled under him as their work...

As far as I'm aware there are people (at least 1) who claim to have authored portions of the HY materials/texts; and for all we know, some of them - if they exist and I suspect they do - may not be scholars either.

He has no educational qualifications for me to take him as a scholar - neither deeni nor dunyavi.

There are too many suspicious things going on with the whole production but the most recent issue regarding Burma highlights one. I've already mentioned the issue I have with it very briefly in this thread and those thoughts were brought on due in part by the transcription of one episode of the HY show (English translation) posted here.

To each their own. I can tell you that I have no intention to compare myself with a scholar nor do I intend to become a scholar however, if I see something wrong, I feel duty bound to warn and inform my brothers and sisters - within my capacity. Obviously we all will choose to do as we please and we each will bear the consequences of our choices. The waters aren't so gray to me in this instance. If they are for others, perhaps it is best to steer clear just for that purpose alone.

09-04-2012, 02:57 AM	#32
Svatudjw Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 536 Senior Member	...And there is no one claiming the works titled under him as their work... As far as I'm aware there are people (at least 1) who claim to have authored portions of the HY materials/texts; and for all we know, some of them - if they exist and I suspect they do - may not be scholars either. He has no educational qualifications for me to take him as a scholar - neither deeni nor dunyavi. There are too many suspicious things going on with the whole production but the most recent issue regarding Burma highlights one. I've already mentioned the issue I have with it very briefly in this thread and those thoughts were brought on due in part by the transcription of one episode of the HY show (English translation) posted here. To each their own. I can tell you that I have no intention to compare myself with a scholar nor do I intend to become a scholar however, if I see something wrong, I feel duty bound to warn and inform my brothers and sisters - within my capacity. Obviously we all will choose to do as we please and we each will bear the consequences of our choices. The waters aren't so gray to me in this instance. If they are for others, perhaps it is best to steer clear just for that purpose alone.
	Quote