DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Zina conviction - 4 (male?) witnesses who have seen the act?

**palantownia** · 09-04-2012, 02:56 AM

[QUOTE=uali3;808647]

No, there is no 'original persons testimony' backed by the 4. Its the actual testimonies by 4 male witnesses. Which is very unlikely, if not impossible, because rajm is not meant to be carried out very often in the first place.[/Q

Do you know why the 4 witnesses have to be male? Please reply. JZK

No I don't, possibly because some women lie to hurt other women.

Or because the women are not "known" to be pious because they do not socialize with the males thus taking a testimony from her could create an argument about if she is even a pious muslim or not because no one has seen her do good except other women etc.

there good be a million reasons or just one do not doubt Allah he knows why he doesn't want to take the testimony of females or why he judges them to half of a mans testimony in most/all cases.

and If the kafir don't like it, I don't care I am not embarrassed by my deen or our law regardless how it looks at first glance to those who hate Islam to begin with because they can't find anything else to hate.

09-04-2012, 02:56 AM	#11
palantownia Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 431 Senior Member	[QUOTE=uali3;808647] No, there is no 'original persons testimony' backed by the 4. Its the actual testimonies by 4 male witnesses. Which is very unlikely, if not impossible, because rajm is not meant to be carried out very often in the first place.[/Q Do you know why the 4 witnesses have to be male? Please reply. JZK No I don't, possibly because some women lie to hurt other women. Or because the women are not "known" to be pious because they do not socialize with the males thus taking a testimony from her could create an argument about if she is even a pious muslim or not because no one has seen her do good except other women etc. there good be a million reasons or just one do not doubt Allah he knows why he doesn't want to take the testimony of females or why he judges them to half of a mans testimony in most/all cases. and If the kafir don't like it, I don't care I am not embarrassed by my deen or our law regardless how it looks at first glance to those who hate Islam to begin with because they can't find anything else to hate.
	Quote