DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**Singukil** · 08-04-2008, 05:55 PM

Wassalaam

Let me tell you I belong to Saharanpur, U.P., it’s a very orthodox place & people too are same, I tried to discuss it with many people including Tabligh Jamat & Madarsa Mazahir Uloom Hadith faculty years back but I was labeled as Munkar e Hadith, Ahle Quran etc. Ironically you can’t have a free & honest discussion on such sensitive matters with most of people.

I am into service & time is a constraint so I have not been able to discuss it in details with any renowned scholar moreover it’s such a topic that the dialogue turns into an argument & I can’t do that with an Ulema.

I have written same letter recently to at least 30 people ranging from Deoband, Nadva to people like Harun Yahya & Zakir Naik, let’s see what these people have to say about it so far I only heard from Mr. Suheil Laher.

The book by Hawkins is ‘Brief history of time’ & other such articles.

NOTE:- I'd prefer not to be understood than being misunderstood so please ask for clarification on my query.

08-04-2008, 05:55 PM	#3
Singukil Join Date Nov 2005 Posts 386 Senior Member	Wassalaam Let me tell you I belong to Saharanpur, U.P., it’s a very orthodox place & people too are same, I tried to discuss it with many people including Tabligh Jamat & Madarsa Mazahir Uloom Hadith faculty years back but I was labeled as Munkar e Hadith, Ahle Quran etc. Ironically you can’t have a free & honest discussion on such sensitive matters with most of people. I am into service & time is a constraint so I have not been able to discuss it in details with any renowned scholar moreover it’s such a topic that the dialogue turns into an argument & I can’t do that with an Ulema. I have written same letter recently to at least 30 people ranging from Deoband, Nadva to people like Harun Yahya & Zakir Naik, let’s see what these people have to say about it so far I only heard from Mr. Suheil Laher. The book by Hawkins is ‘Brief history of time’ & other such articles. NOTE:- I'd prefer not to be understood than being misunderstood so please ask for clarification on my query.
	Quote