BC i saw that bump from Billings, it was an ABC game but someone said footage can't be used from ABC broadcast games, i guess that is because it can disadvantage the two sides who are playing in that game. But the bump to me looked legit as you said, a hip and shoulder but yes it was off the ball a bit but when i saw it i didn't think it looked a huge hit, Sinclair looked like he went down like Autumn leaves. But when you are not expecting it and don't brace yourself it comes as a bit of a shock and Billings is hard man. I reckon every club in the WAFL would like to have him and every club needs one or two like this. I just think it's a case of Billings hitting him at the right time and must have knocked the wind out of him. If it was with and elbow or forearm to the head then that's a different matter. No doubt one of your boys is going to line Billings up next time. Hopefully the umpires are watching Billings when that time comes and your boy gets a holiday!