DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**Buyemae** · 09-04-2012, 04:22 AM

Moulana Sulaiman Chowksi (teacher in Madressah Zakariyyah, Lenasia) said once in his bayan that if we had seen the Sahabah 's lifestyle, we would think they are mad, and if they saw our lifestyle, they would think we are munaafiq. The same would apply in the questioning we do of every single thing.

Are you are implying that anyone who may ask such questions is a munafiq? Has it occurred to you that most reverts would have gone through this sort of questioning in order to gain their imaan? You are obviously born a muslim and take your religion for granted and have never really needed to look for answers. I'm pretty sure that even the sahaba (ra) asked these types of questions before they accepted Islam and probably even afterwards.

You might have a stronger imaan than most people but there will many muslims who will have questions and I would hope decent scholars are willing to give suitable answers without giving them the third degree or putting their imaan into question.

09-04-2012, 04:22 AM	#40
Buyemae Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 607 Senior Member	Moulana Sulaiman Chowksi (teacher in Madressah Zakariyyah, Lenasia) said once in his bayan that if we had seen the Sahabah 's lifestyle, we would think they are mad, and if they saw our lifestyle, they would think we are munaafiq. The same would apply in the questioning we do of every single thing. Are you are implying that anyone who may ask such questions is a munafiq? Has it occurred to you that most reverts would have gone through this sort of questioning in order to gain their imaan? You are obviously born a muslim and take your religion for granted and have never really needed to look for answers. I'm pretty sure that even the sahaba (ra) asked these types of questions before they accepted Islam and probably even afterwards. You might have a stronger imaan than most people but there will many muslims who will have questions and I would hope decent scholars are willing to give suitable answers without giving them the third degree or putting their imaan into question.
	Quote