DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**Shemker394** · 10-16-2011, 11:34 PM

Hi all.
I may be wrong, but it seems to me that B.W.B. is suggestive of Karma within a finite framework.

Well, there are members here that do not. The problem is that such is grounded in faith, believe, superstition and speculation.

I have always had problems with Karma relevant to the claim that it is a perfectly just law. It is the popular outlook people handle about Karma. This attitude can end in ideas like those where people believe that a baby born with a deformity or with any other kind of disadvantage is because a bad Karma gained through a misbehaviour in -literal- past lives believes. I do not go with such believes.

That said, it seems to me, that for Karma to operate in any deep cosmic sense [...] Murchovsky, is this about the law of physics that can determine in some way the behaviour of the cosmos? or is this about a kind of ruler like the one who do not play dice?

some form of long term, post mortem sentient "reasoning" or whatever, hard to find a word for it, would be neccessary.......

Is this idea grounded in the rebirth doctrine?

I really think that the hole issue is highly speculative and, most of the times, I have seen, it works to have some kind of meaningful explanation -relief- of something we really do not know. When mindfulness in the present moment, speculative defilements fade away making possible to awake.

10-16-2011, 11:34 PM	#3
Shemker394 Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 416 Senior Member	Hi all. I may be wrong, but it seems to me that B.W.B. is suggestive of Karma within a finite framework. Well, there are members here that do not. The problem is that such is grounded in faith, believe, superstition and speculation. I have always had problems with Karma relevant to the claim that it is a perfectly just law. It is the popular outlook people handle about Karma. This attitude can end in ideas like those where people believe that a baby born with a deformity or with any other kind of disadvantage is because a bad Karma gained through a misbehaviour in -literal- past lives believes. I do not go with such believes. That said, it seems to me, that for Karma to operate in any deep cosmic sense [...] Murchovsky, is this about the law of physics that can determine in some way the behaviour of the cosmos? or is this about a kind of ruler like the one who do not play dice? some form of long term, post mortem sentient "reasoning" or whatever, hard to find a word for it, would be neccessary....... Is this idea grounded in the rebirth doctrine? I really think that the hole issue is highly speculative and, most of the times, I have seen, it works to have some kind of meaningful explanation -relief- of something we really do not know. When mindfulness in the present moment, speculative defilements fade away making possible to awake.
	Quote