[Zysyewgg]

So is buddhism minus the reincarnation and stuff just as good as Buddhism with reincarnation? Has anyone tried both?

Thanks.

Ha-ha..."tried both" sound also a bit humorist to me...no offense.... No one here has tried both of course, because we are all stuck in our present bodies and lives. And if amongst us any kind rebirth is taking place...we will never know...and the "re-born" will never remember that she or he has ever been here in this forum.
This of course is no statement from my side for rebirth or reincarnation as "true facts" or so. It is pure and plain speculative and theoretic. For what ever we try to seek and find useful for our practice... we are here and now and need to follow the path that lays before us. There is no reward system in Buddhism like a reincarnation into higher realms....that would be an entirely wrong reason to become- or to be a Buddhist.... and to continue practicing Buddhism (of any Buddhist Sect)