Ameen I agree. I only wrote something because I genuinely wasn't sure if he was a troll planting anti-Muslim threads for future people to find on SF. I didn't want any guest to think we accepted what he said in any way. I think it's a shame that we only knew him through the internet. If one of us had known him in person, perhaps we could have talked to him better and explained to him the truth in Islam. Whilst the 'Nation of Islam' for example has some strange beliefs, it is undeniable through that many people first encountered real islam and so became Muslim. May Allah swt give him Hidaya.