DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Question about the authenticity of a hadith

**MizzDaizzy** · 11-27-2008, 12:30 AM

In order for someone to atttribute a saying to Nabi they are required to produce the chain for it. Until then, their attribution is worthless.
Those opposing them aren't required to prove it to be fabricated, rather those quoting it have to prove its authenticity.

To understand, if someone claimed that Nabi mentioned forums to be haram!
If we ask him for the proof, he could claim that it is mentioned in hadith, even though he doesn't have a chain for it and that if you oppose him, please show which book of fabricated ahadith classified it as a fabrication!

What would be a suitable reply to such an ignoramous?

Assalamualaikum mufti saab,

Isn´t same case happened in fazaile amal a few time, where sheikh self says: i didn´t find the hadith´s chain by myself but it is in this and that book. Where was the need to mention such doubtful hadith?

11-27-2008, 12:30 AM	#11
MizzDaizzy Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 566 Senior Member	In order for someone to atttribute a saying to Nabi they are required to produce the chain for it. Until then, their attribution is worthless. Those opposing them aren't required to prove it to be fabricated, rather those quoting it have to prove its authenticity. To understand, if someone claimed that Nabi mentioned forums to be haram! If we ask him for the proof, he could claim that it is mentioned in hadith, even though he doesn't have a chain for it and that if you oppose him, please show which book of fabricated ahadith classified it as a fabrication! What would be a suitable reply to such an ignoramous? Assalamualaikum mufti saab, Isn´t same case happened in fazaile amal a few time, where sheikh self says: i didn´t find the hadith´s chain by myself but it is in this and that book. Where was the need to mention such doubtful hadith?
	Quote