DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**eXC3Kvnn** · 08-08-2012, 04:46 AM

Well in that case then ....there should be a fatwa against junk food too since it's bad for health.

What I'm saying brother is...unless there's a clear nas of something being haraam, scholars cannot just make things haraam willy nilly.

Let us remember, this is one of the reasons why Allah was displeased with Bani Israel...they gave themselves the power to declare things halaal and haraam....and they made a lot of good stuff haraam.

It is no joking matter ...these scholars will be asked about it on yammul qiyamah.

I understand, I'm just saying that out of all their arguments for Tahreem, this could be the strongest one (if they can prove that it is extremely harmful to the body).

I don't think it's Haram.. But I don't find it attractive (my tastes), and I don't think it's a healthy habit.

08-08-2012, 04:46 AM	#35
eXC3Kvnn Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 404 Senior Member	Well in that case then ....there should be a fatwa against junk food too since it's bad for health. What I'm saying brother is...unless there's a clear nas of something being haraam, scholars cannot just make things haraam willy nilly. Let us remember, this is one of the reasons why Allah was displeased with Bani Israel...they gave themselves the power to declare things halaal and haraam....and they made a lot of good stuff haraam. It is no joking matter ...these scholars will be asked about it on yammul qiyamah. I understand, I'm just saying that out of all their arguments for Tahreem, this could be the strongest one (if they can prove that it is extremely harmful to the body). I don't think it's Haram.. But I don't find it attractive (my tastes), and I don't think it's a healthy habit.
	Quote