DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Is rafa-yadain necessary behind Wahabi Imam?

**Meenepek** · 08-25-2010, 12:43 AM

I object to the word ever/never, because our Prophet did rafa-yadain at some point and it is not that he never/ever did it

With the utmost respect you have misunderstood my point.

By "necessary" I mean "obligation" and Rafa Yadain is classed as "Sunnah" and not as necessary i.e. not obligatory in Salah by anyone.

There are acts which are regarded as "Fardh (obligations)" and are therefore "necessary" in Salah and abstaining from them will render your Salah invalid.

Rafa Yadain doesn't fall in that category and thats all I am saying. If you disagree with the mater and regard Rafa Yadain as "necessary" or in other words "obligatory" or "Fardh" please provide your evidence.

08-25-2010, 12:43 AM	#5
Meenepek Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 500 Senior Member	I object to the word ever/never, because our Prophet did rafa-yadain at some point and it is not that he never/ever did it With the utmost respect you have misunderstood my point. By "necessary" I mean "obligation" and Rafa Yadain is classed as "Sunnah" and not as necessary i.e. not obligatory in Salah by anyone. There are acts which are regarded as "Fardh (obligations)" and are therefore "necessary" in Salah and abstaining from them will render your Salah invalid. Rafa Yadain doesn't fall in that category and thats all I am saying. If you disagree with the mater and regard Rafa Yadain as "necessary" or in other words "obligatory" or "Fardh" please provide your evidence.
	Quote