[aceriscoolon]

for the responses. Please try and keep this discussion calm. There are no Qadiani/Ahmadiyya on this website, so don't be harsh with your fellow brothers out of anger for an absent sect. Its Ramadan, not jihad time.

A quick google search revealed that both the quotations have been copy pasted from the website of Lahori Jamaa't. http://ahmadiyya.org/movement/maudoodi/letter.htm

And if they quote sahih hadith on their website...would you doubt those hadith too? Have sabr, inshallah someone will provide the proofs you are asking for.

Regarding the Lahori Muhammad Ali, I doubt Deedat would need to rely on his works since refutations of Christianity have been around for centuries- many Muslims studied and refuted the Bible including the likes of Ibn Taymiyyah. Not to mention Christian works regarding things like textual criticism, higher criticism etc have been around for centuries also so refutations of Christianity is nothing new

I recall reading the book that Ahmed Deedat used to back up his work that I think he cites in one of his books, and the preface mentioned the Ahmadiyya. This was a very long time ago, but I remember speaking to some brothers about it and they kind of brushed it off. I can dig around and see if I can find it again. Of course, books have been written on Christian refutation for centuries but this one in particular is from Muhammad Ali and utilized by Ahmed Deedat, which raises some questions.