DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Non-Salafi Hanbali `Ulama

**FUNALA** · 07-19-2012, 03:44 AM

Ok bro, whatever you say. I've seen enough of these debates to know it isn't as simple of a picture as you are making it out to be

And I didn't say they were making taqleed in aqeedah but if you think people don't make taqleed of their ulema when it comes to believing who is Ahlus Sunnah and who is not...

It's extremely simple.

Attack Ibn Taymiyyah, and it allows you to live in a safe bubble were you think the Salafi Aqeedah is something new and didn't exist prior to Ibn Taymiyyah, even though the Ashari books constantly talk about the Hanbalis in general in negative ways.

Okay, people can make taqleed of their ulama, I have no problem with that, however, that taqleed only makes them look stupid when they come to find out that what Ibn Taymiyyah said can be found in any Hanbali book besides his.

Have you ever noticed anyone ever actually present proof that the Hanaabilah differ from ibn Taymiyyah, and how?

07-19-2012, 03:44 AM	#31
FUNALA Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 539 Senior Member	Ok bro, whatever you say. I've seen enough of these debates to know it isn't as simple of a picture as you are making it out to be And I didn't say they were making taqleed in aqeedah but if you think people don't make taqleed of their ulema when it comes to believing who is Ahlus Sunnah and who is not... It's extremely simple. Attack Ibn Taymiyyah, and it allows you to live in a safe bubble were you think the Salafi Aqeedah is something new and didn't exist prior to Ibn Taymiyyah, even though the Ashari books constantly talk about the Hanbalis in general in negative ways. Okay, people can make taqleed of their ulama, I have no problem with that, however, that taqleed only makes them look stupid when they come to find out that what Ibn Taymiyyah said can be found in any Hanbali book besides his. Have you ever noticed anyone ever actually present proof that the Hanaabilah differ from ibn Taymiyyah, and how?
	Quote