Did you just implicate countless Ulema, Honorable Mashaikh, Awliyaa, other righteous members of the Ummah of Rasoolullaah saw, and the general 'awaam of open fisq, cowardice, and even the rejection of such a fard al-Ayn (that includes you too buddy)? If that's what you believe, and that's what you just did ... someone please ban him. Originally Posted by ahmad12 Short answer- Yes