DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**nilliraq** · 07-17-2012, 01:06 AM

I am no 'alim but I'm pretty sure if necessity arises, it becomes permissible. Hitting the face is not allowed even for punishment's sake since it is not a necessity. But if there is no way to defend yourself but to strike the face, it would be permissible due to necessity. In j-had (on the battlefield), there is no clear ruling on avoiding the face, for example, since it may become a necessity. Read here: http://www.sunniforum.com/forum/show...tting-the-Face

u say ur not an alim....then u give an opinion which u are pretty sure is the right one? contradiction there.

and the thread u posted doesnt give an answer for muggings or even jihad. the responder is an admin and is not a scholar on here. and even he says "Allahu alam" for the hitting the face in a mugging or jihad situation.

im concerned about halal and haram in my day to day life thats why i ask this question. i have hit ppl before in the face cos i deemed it necessary. so is my judgement on what i consider necessary enough to make it halal for me?

where are the ulama on this issue??

07-17-2012, 01:06 AM	#23
nilliraq Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 402 Senior Member	I am no 'alim but I'm pretty sure if necessity arises, it becomes permissible. Hitting the face is not allowed even for punishment's sake since it is not a necessity. But if there is no way to defend yourself but to strike the face, it would be permissible due to necessity. In j-had (on the battlefield), there is no clear ruling on avoiding the face, for example, since it may become a necessity. Read here: http://www.sunniforum.com/forum/show...tting-the-Face u say ur not an alim....then u give an opinion which u are pretty sure is the right one? contradiction there. and the thread u posted doesnt give an answer for muggings or even jihad. the responder is an admin and is not a scholar on here. and even he says "Allahu alam" for the hitting the face in a mugging or jihad situation. im concerned about halal and haram in my day to day life thats why i ask this question. i have hit ppl before in the face cos i deemed it necessary. so is my judgement on what i consider necessary enough to make it halal for me? where are the ulama on this issue??
	Quote