DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**Alliopeti** · 07-17-2012, 01:18 AM

u say ur not an alim....then u give an opinion which u are pretty sure is the right one? contradiction there.

Sorry brother, but from what ulama have always stated is that when necessity arises, something haraam can become halaal.

and the thread u posted doesnt give an answer for muggings or even jihad. the responder is an admin and is not a scholar on here. and even he says "Allahu alam" for the hitting the face in a mugging or jihad situation. As I said, there is no clear ruling of punching the face in j-had since fighting to kill is also permissible in j-had but not acceptable otherwise.

im concerned about halal and haram in my day to day life thats why i ask this question. i have hit ppl before in the face cos i deemed it necessary. so is my judgement on what i consider necessary enough to make it halal for me?

where are the ulama on this issue?? Ulama usually post in the Fiqh section. Make this thread over there and explain your situation

.

07-17-2012, 01:18 AM	#25
Alliopeti Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 435 Senior Member	u say ur not an alim....then u give an opinion which u are pretty sure is the right one? contradiction there. Sorry brother, but from what ulama have always stated is that when necessity arises, something haraam can become halaal. and the thread u posted doesnt give an answer for muggings or even jihad. the responder is an admin and is not a scholar on here. and even he says "Allahu alam" for the hitting the face in a mugging or jihad situation. As I said, there is no clear ruling of punching the face in j-had since fighting to kill is also permissible in j-had but not acceptable otherwise. im concerned about halal and haram in my day to day life thats why i ask this question. i have hit ppl before in the face cos i deemed it necessary. so is my judgement on what i consider necessary enough to make it halal for me? where are the ulama on this issue?? Ulama usually post in the Fiqh section. Make this thread over there and explain your situation .
	Quote