DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Spiritual harms of argumentation and debates

**U5pz6B71** · 12-10-2011, 01:25 PM

First of all i should thank brother Ahmed of muftisays.com. He is the one who wrote the article.

Peaceful discussion with an open mind by quoting the ulema is always welcome. But one should accept if erred. Most often ppl go to great lengths just to twist things to suit their opinion. Also as shaykh Riyadul Haqq says leave the Fiqh to the ulema. If anyone has doubts post fatwas of the ulema rather than 'deriving' it ourselves. I have myself have erred quoting single hadith on fiqh issues.

But if someone tries to propagate deviant beliefs refute them properly. That too by providing proper daleel.

But what usually happens is we usually have convinced ourselves of an opinion, and we will not accept even if we are proved wrong. More often there are two or more valid opinions but we do not accept that either.

12-10-2011, 01:25 PM	#5
U5pz6B71 Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 490 Senior Member	First of all i should thank brother Ahmed of muftisays.com. He is the one who wrote the article. Peaceful discussion with an open mind by quoting the ulema is always welcome. But one should accept if erred. Most often ppl go to great lengths just to twist things to suit their opinion. Also as shaykh Riyadul Haqq says leave the Fiqh to the ulema. If anyone has doubts post fatwas of the ulema rather than 'deriving' it ourselves. I have myself have erred quoting single hadith on fiqh issues. But if someone tries to propagate deviant beliefs refute them properly. That too by providing proper daleel. But what usually happens is we usually have convinced ourselves of an opinion, and we will not accept even if we are proved wrong. More often there are two or more valid opinions but we do not accept that either.
	Quote