DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - 24 hrs Sin: To Shave the Beard or To Trim it Less than one fist in length

**Patgaepx** · 03-28-2010, 06:54 PM

As for the application of this concept to one keeping his garment below his ankle, it could be understood on the basis of the action not being a momentary one whose effect is long lasting (like shaving the beard), instead it is an action that repeats itself , allowing one to raise it at any second, so the continuous leaving of it, is in reality continuous perpetration of the action of keeping it below the ankle.
This wouldn't apply to the beard, as it doesn't have this tajaddud (continuous repetition) in it.

Is it that you disagree with the '24 hour sin' saying for shaving the beard but not for the ankes Mufti saheb?

If so, could not the 'allowing oneself to raise it at any second' apply to many other sins which people do habitually which could be left while doing them?

03-28-2010, 06:54 PM	#23
Patgaepx Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 419 Senior Member	As for the application of this concept to one keeping his garment below his ankle, it could be understood on the basis of the action not being a momentary one whose effect is long lasting (like shaving the beard), instead it is an action that repeats itself , allowing one to raise it at any second, so the continuous leaving of it, is in reality continuous perpetration of the action of keeping it below the ankle. This wouldn't apply to the beard, as it doesn't have this tajaddud (continuous repetition) in it. Is it that you disagree with the '24 hour sin' saying for shaving the beard but not for the ankes Mufti saheb? If so, could not the 'allowing oneself to raise it at any second' apply to many other sins which people do habitually which could be left while doing them?
	Quote