DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Dawat-e-Islami

**crycleascentyv** · 07-08-2008, 11:53 PM

Okay br. Kang.. from what you have shared with us.. now we can say that there is not much different between the two. (no pun and no disrespect).. I like that you are involved in some deeni work.. Allah make it a means of hidaya to you and all around you. Amin

Now.. TJ or Tableeghi Jamaat is pretty much the same tarteeb which you have mentioned.. with slight changes here and there.. They are also hanafi and follow deobandi Ulama..

It would be incorrect to say that TJ and deobandi are same.. because I have met numerous barelwies, ahl hadeeth, Jamaati brothers in TJ as well.. but predominantly they are deobandies. But to say that.. you will need to know what is meant by saying so and so is a deobandi.

Deobandi is a methodology, a mindset and it is that of the Akabir Ulama of DU Deoband.. Basic apparent difference which you would see between the deobandi and D-I is the absence of Zawaid in the actions.. Since DI is hard rooted in barelwi, you will see salami, giyarwi, khatam etc.. deobandi masajid are pretty much void of these activities.. here an there you might fine masajid conducting khatm khuwajgan etc.. but none of the other things like niyaz.. Other aparent change would be the emphasis on naa't.. There is an immense ghuloo of recitation of na't among barelwis.. so this may be present in DI as well.

Finally, as I have understood from my interaction in both circles.. the acceptance of somethin as a sunnah may be more academic based in deobandi people, while it is more emotionally based in barelwies.. This is also present in DI... because once you are there .. the phrase is either madani batein, or sunnati batein.. which instills ghuloo in the awaam to think that these "batain" are infact an establishment within sunnah...

Q. How much time you spend in a day to correct tajweed in the quran.. and what is the tarteeb for that?

07-08-2008, 11:53 PM	#39
crycleascentyv Join Date Nov 2005 Posts 577 Senior Member	Okay br. Kang.. from what you have shared with us.. now we can say that there is not much different between the two. (no pun and no disrespect).. I like that you are involved in some deeni work.. Allah make it a means of hidaya to you and all around you. Amin Now.. TJ or Tableeghi Jamaat is pretty much the same tarteeb which you have mentioned.. with slight changes here and there.. They are also hanafi and follow deobandi Ulama.. It would be incorrect to say that TJ and deobandi are same.. because I have met numerous barelwies, ahl hadeeth, Jamaati brothers in TJ as well.. but predominantly they are deobandies. But to say that.. you will need to know what is meant by saying so and so is a deobandi. Deobandi is a methodology, a mindset and it is that of the Akabir Ulama of DU Deoband.. Basic apparent difference which you would see between the deobandi and D-I is the absence of Zawaid in the actions.. Since DI is hard rooted in barelwi, you will see salami, giyarwi, khatam etc.. deobandi masajid are pretty much void of these activities.. here an there you might fine masajid conducting khatm khuwajgan etc.. but none of the other things like niyaz.. Other aparent change would be the emphasis on naa't.. There is an immense ghuloo of recitation of na't among barelwis.. so this may be present in DI as well. Finally, as I have understood from my interaction in both circles.. the acceptance of somethin as a sunnah may be more academic based in deobandi people, while it is more emotionally based in barelwies.. This is also present in DI... because once you are there .. the phrase is either madani batein, or sunnati batein.. which instills ghuloo in the awaam to think that these "batain" are infact an establishment within sunnah... Q. How much time you spend in a day to correct tajweed in the quran.. and what is the tarteeb for that?
	Quote