DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Shaykh Imran Hosein (HA) & Space/Time Explanation?

**Celeliamend** · 06-15-2012, 09:35 PM

As-salâmu 'alaykum wa rahmatullâhi wa barakâtuhu,

In reagrds to Tamin Dari (RA) meeting Dajjal, thsi is taken from Shaykh Imran Hossein's official website under the question and answer section.
http://www.imranhosein.org/faq/55-si...n-of-time.html

The question was asked "How could Tamim al-Dari have seen Dajjal if he is not in our dimension of time?"
The answer was "I do not believe that this was an actual journey. Rather, I believe that Tamim al-Dari most probably had a vision and not an actual experience with a meeting with Dajjal in our dimension of space and time."

In reference to Dajjal's island being the UK and then taking the above answer into account I as a fan of Shaykh Hossein do find it difficult to understand and will contact Shaykh for an explanation.

In regards to 'How can a boat float along from Jeddah to UK with that level of technology?' brother a miracle of Allah can make the boat travel from Jeddah to the UK in a blink of an eye such as the way the companions of the cave explained in surah Kahf slept for almost 300 years, just the way Our beloved (saws) was taken to the heavens so this shouldn't be a question to worry about but the rest of it does require deeper explanation.

Jazak-Allah
Was-salâmu 'alaykum wa rahmatullâhi wa barakatuhu`

Brother,

So in the first instance the Shaykh (HA) is rejecting the opinion of overwhelming majority of Muslims and claiming that Tamim Dari (RA) had a vision and it wasn’t a physically contact.

In general here is what I find difficult, you either try to make rational (logical or scientific) explanations OR you rely on these matters being of Karaamah. You can’t chop/change when you are pushed into a corner and asked for an explanation.

You can’t claim PHYSICAL MEETING of Tamim Dari (RA) which implies

That he entered another continuum
And then also claim that his boat ride from Jeddah to UK was miraculous.

If our Shaykh (HA) is claiming that Tamim Dari (RA) had a vision then he is under no obligation to explain the boatride but then he has to clearly say that I am departing from the understanding of all Scholars and claiming this to be a vision.

Do you get me?

06-15-2012, 09:35 PM	#8
Celeliamend Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 368 Senior Member	As-salâmu 'alaykum wa rahmatullâhi wa barakâtuhu, In reagrds to Tamin Dari (RA) meeting Dajjal, thsi is taken from Shaykh Imran Hossein's official website under the question and answer section. http://www.imranhosein.org/faq/55-si...n-of-time.html The question was asked "How could Tamim al-Dari have seen Dajjal if he is not in our dimension of time?" The answer was "I do not believe that this was an actual journey. Rather, I believe that Tamim al-Dari most probably had a vision and not an actual experience with a meeting with Dajjal in our dimension of space and time." In reference to Dajjal's island being the UK and then taking the above answer into account I as a fan of Shaykh Hossein do find it difficult to understand and will contact Shaykh for an explanation. In regards to 'How can a boat float along from Jeddah to UK with that level of technology?' brother a miracle of Allah can make the boat travel from Jeddah to the UK in a blink of an eye such as the way the companions of the cave explained in surah Kahf slept for almost 300 years, just the way Our beloved (saws) was taken to the heavens so this shouldn't be a question to worry about but the rest of it does require deeper explanation. Jazak-Allah Was-salâmu 'alaykum wa rahmatullâhi wa barakatuhu` Brother, So in the first instance the Shaykh (HA) is rejecting the opinion of overwhelming majority of Muslims and claiming that Tamim Dari (RA) had a vision and it wasn’t a physically contact. In general here is what I find difficult, you either try to make rational (logical or scientific) explanations OR you rely on these matters being of Karaamah. You can’t chop/change when you are pushed into a corner and asked for an explanation. You can’t claim PHYSICAL MEETING of Tamim Dari (RA) which implies That he entered another continuum And then also claim that his boat ride from Jeddah to UK was miraculous. If our Shaykh (HA) is claiming that Tamim Dari (RA) had a vision then he is under no obligation to explain the boatride but then he has to clearly say that I am departing from the understanding of all Scholars and claiming this to be a vision. Do you get me?
	Quote