DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - mixing madha-hib

**indartwm** · 07-12-2012, 05:56 AM

Excerpt from the book, Who are the Blind Followers?:

When people do not restrict themselves to one madh-hab, then gradually an environment of following the concessions of the Imams will come into existence. In Fiq-h, this is termed as "Tatabbu'ur Rukhas". The scholars have rendered severe warnings about this. Imam Baihaqi quotes Imam Awza'i Rahimahumallahu Ta'ala as saying: "The person who adopts all the rarities of the 'Ulama' leaves (the precincts of) Islam." Imam 'Ali Ibn Al-Ja'd Rahmatullahi 'alaih attributes the following statement to the great Sulaiman At-Taimi Rahmatullahi 'alaih: "If you practice upon the concessions of every 'Alim, then every evil will be gathered in you."

'Hafiz Ibn 'Abdul Barr Rahmatullahi 'alaih comments on this statement: "There is consensus on this. I am not aware of any opposing view on it." It is reported from the two great scholars of Hadith, Imam Yahya Al-Qattan and Imam Ahmad Ibn Hambal Rahimahumallahu Ta'ala that such a person is a fasiq (transgressor). May Allah protect us.

07-12-2012, 05:56 AM	#8
indartwm Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 429 Senior Member	Excerpt from the book, Who are the Blind Followers?: When people do not restrict themselves to one madh-hab, then gradually an environment of following the concessions of the Imams will come into existence. In Fiq-h, this is termed as "Tatabbu'ur Rukhas". The scholars have rendered severe warnings about this. Imam Baihaqi quotes Imam Awza'i Rahimahumallahu Ta'ala as saying: "The person who adopts all the rarities of the 'Ulama' leaves (the precincts of) Islam." Imam 'Ali Ibn Al-Ja'd Rahmatullahi 'alaih attributes the following statement to the great Sulaiman At-Taimi Rahmatullahi 'alaih: "If you practice upon the concessions of every 'Alim, then every evil will be gathered in you." 'Hafiz Ibn 'Abdul Barr Rahmatullahi 'alaih comments on this statement: "There is consensus on this. I am not aware of any opposing view on it." It is reported from the two great scholars of Hadith, Imam Yahya Al-Qattan and Imam Ahmad Ibn Hambal Rahimahumallahu Ta'ala that such a person is a fasiq (transgressor). May Allah protect us.
	Quote