DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Help Required: Authenticity of hadith about the Prophet Muhammad (SAW) being alive

**ViktorialHDY** · 07-09-2012, 03:59 AM

Assalamu Alaikum everyone,

The following image is being shared on facebook.

557121_342952775780474_1311385082_n.jpg

Its in urdu, so i will explain what it says. Its says on top "The being alive of the Prophet Muhammad

in grave" and then it quotes a Hadith that says:

Abu Huraira (RA) narrated that the Prophet Muhammad

said: If someone sends blessings on me then without a doubt Allah Taala has returned my soul (and my attention is diverted towards the one who sends the blessing), such that i reply to his blessings.

Well, i have very very limited knowledge, may Allah forgive me for my ignorance. But the thing is that i've been led to believe contradictory to what this hadith says. Now, all the references mentioned regarding this hadith are from books other than the six authentic collections except one which says: Abu Dawood Fi Sunan Kitaab al-manasik, ziyarat-al-quboor, 218/2. I don't know arabic neither do i have a copy of Abu Dawood. The ones i could find online were just labelled Kitaab so and so, without the subtopics like "ziyarat-al-quboor" etc. I really need help, if someone could confirm or reject the authenticity of this hadith being present in Abu Dawood, or in any one of the other 5 authentic ahadith collections!

May Allah Taala forgive my and other people's ignorance and show us the right path and make us follow it, ameen.

07-09-2012, 03:59 AM	#1
ViktorialHDY Join Date Nov 2005 Posts 393 Senior Member	Help Required: Authenticity of hadith about the Prophet Muhammad (SAW) being alive Assalamu Alaikum everyone, The following image is being shared on facebook. 557121_342952775780474_1311385082_n.jpg Its in urdu, so i will explain what it says. Its says on top "The being alive of the Prophet Muhammad in grave" and then it quotes a Hadith that says: Abu Huraira (RA) narrated that the Prophet Muhammad said: If someone sends blessings on me then without a doubt Allah Taala has returned my soul (and my attention is diverted towards the one who sends the blessing), such that i reply to his blessings. Well, i have very very limited knowledge, may Allah forgive me for my ignorance. But the thing is that i've been led to believe contradictory to what this hadith says. Now, all the references mentioned regarding this hadith are from books other than the six authentic collections except one which says: Abu Dawood Fi Sunan Kitaab al-manasik, ziyarat-al-quboor, 218/2. I don't know arabic neither do i have a copy of Abu Dawood. The ones i could find online were just labelled Kitaab so and so, without the subtopics like "ziyarat-al-quboor" etc. I really need help, if someone could confirm or reject the authenticity of this hadith being present in Abu Dawood, or in any one of the other 5 authentic ahadith collections! May Allah Taala forgive my and other people's ignorance and show us the right path and make us follow it, ameen.
	Quote