DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**Inettypofonee** · 07-05-2012, 10:15 AM

Who said worshipping on this night is only done by South Asians?

Have you travelled? Arabian Peninsula? East Africa?

Even if all Ahadith on it are weak their collective strength makes it strong, this was noted by even Salafi Scholars like al-Albani and al-Mubrakfuri, Ibn Taymiyyah himself said the Salaf used to worship on this night.

Im sure you must have read articles for it? or are you completely oblivious to them?

Brother, if you want to celebrate this night then fine. But there's a strong view that this night is bid'ah. Why would you celebrate a night which has so much doubts surrounding it? Its safer to leave matter of doubt. I personally believe its a bid'ah because there's a lot of evidence that support this view.

07-05-2012, 10:15 AM	#27
Inettypofonee Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 357 Senior Member	Who said worshipping on this night is only done by South Asians? Have you travelled? Arabian Peninsula? East Africa? Even if all Ahadith on it are weak their collective strength makes it strong, this was noted by even Salafi Scholars like al-Albani and al-Mubrakfuri, Ibn Taymiyyah himself said the Salaf used to worship on this night. Im sure you must have read articles for it? or are you completely oblivious to them? Brother, if you want to celebrate this night then fine. But there's a strong view that this night is bid'ah. Why would you celebrate a night which has so much doubts surrounding it? Its safer to leave matter of doubt. I personally believe its a bid'ah because there's a lot of evidence that support this view.
	Quote