DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**Nadin Maison** · 07-03-2012, 08:25 PM

Of course not - that's not what I'm saying. But to say that this or that practice is un-Islamic is not our right to do so. First of all, we are not scholars. Second of all, we are not Shafi'is. Does it make sense for the Ahnaaf to criticize the Hanabilah for not keeping their trousers above their ankles? Does it make sense for the Hanabilah to criticize the Ahnaaf for not reciting the tasmiyah before wudhu?

my point is that it can be argued both ways i.e. respect the the opinion of those who erect graves or respect the opinion of those who consider graves should be levelled

07-03-2012, 08:25 PM	#40
Nadin Maison Join Date Nov 2005 Posts 376 Senior Member	Of course not - that's not what I'm saying. But to say that this or that practice is un-Islamic is not our right to do so. First of all, we are not scholars. Second of all, we are not Shafi'is. Does it make sense for the Ahnaaf to criticize the Hanabilah for not keeping their trousers above their ankles? Does it make sense for the Hanabilah to criticize the Ahnaaf for not reciting the tasmiyah before wudhu? my point is that it can be argued both ways i.e. respect the the opinion of those who erect graves or respect the opinion of those who consider graves should be levelled
	Quote