DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**unsamiSlini** · 12-05-2009, 06:14 PM

One saying i've heard, and is very famous is, "the scholars of my Ummah are like the Prophets of Bani Isra'il", Hafidh Sakhawi says, "our Shaykh (ibn Hajar) and those before him, Damiri and Zakarakshi, 'It has no basis.

Just to add more scholars name who agree with the grading of this hadith as fabricated : Ibn hajar(rh),Imam suyuti(rh).Mulla ali qari(rh), imam shawqani(rh).

Another popular one which is also known as hadith: "Hub al-Watan e min al-Iman " Love of Country is part of Faith (Iman)". Allamah saghani(rh) and Mulla ali qari(rh) said among the muhaddithin, this statement has no basis.

Hadith regardiong eating salt:
Start eating with salt and finish also with salt, cause its medicine of 70 illness Imam bayhaqi,ibn jawzi,ibn qayyim,imam suyuti, allamah ibn arraq (rh) all said this one is fabricated. There is also a similar version:
The person who takes salt before and after eating, he is save from 360 desease imam suyuti and ibn arraq(rh) said this is also fabricated.

Some details about Salt :

Salt and Sunnah

Sunnah way of cutting nails:

This is not a sunnah however, it is preferable.

Opinion of ulama regarding this practise

12-05-2009, 06:14 PM	#22
unsamiSlini Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 381 Senior Member	The Story of Bilal One saying i've heard, and is very famous is, "the scholars of my Ummah are like the Prophets of Bani Isra'il", Hafidh Sakhawi says, "our Shaykh (ibn Hajar) and those before him, Damiri and Zakarakshi, 'It has no basis. Just to add more scholars name who agree with the grading of this hadith as fabricated : Ibn hajar(rh),Imam suyuti(rh).Mulla ali qari(rh), imam shawqani(rh). Another popular one which is also known as hadith: "Hub al-Watan e min al-Iman " Love of Country is part of Faith (Iman)". Allamah saghani(rh) and Mulla ali qari(rh) said among the muhaddithin, this statement has no basis. Hadith regardiong eating salt: Start eating with salt and finish also with salt, cause its medicine of 70 illness Imam bayhaqi,ibn jawzi,ibn qayyim,imam suyuti, allamah ibn arraq (rh) all said this one is fabricated. There is also a similar version: The person who takes salt before and after eating, he is save from 360 desease imam suyuti and ibn arraq(rh) said this is also fabricated. Some details about Salt : Salt and Sunnah Sunnah way of cutting nails: This is not a sunnah however, it is preferable. Opinion of ulama regarding this practise
	Quote