DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**Malinguenem** · 12-05-2009, 08:43 PM

The Story of Bilal

But make sure you read what Hadrat Mufti Husain sahib mentioned:

This is a heavily disputed narration amongst the muhaddithin.

You have Hafiz Ibn Hajr, Adh-Dhahabi, Mulla Ali al-Qari, Ibn al-Arraq etc all classifying it as a fabrication, while Allamah Subki etc classifed it as hasan!
I go with the first, but you will find many taking Allamah Subki's view.

As Ahmed al-Ghumari mentioned "Ibn Hajr will never classify a narration as a fabrication unless its spuriousness is clear like the sun at midday". (al-Mughir)

12-05-2009, 08:43 PM	#23
Malinguenem Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 424 Senior Member	The Story of Bilal But make sure you read what Hadrat Mufti Husain sahib mentioned: This is a heavily disputed narration amongst the muhaddithin. You have Hafiz Ibn Hajr, Adh-Dhahabi, Mulla Ali al-Qari, Ibn al-Arraq etc all classifying it as a fabrication, while Allamah Subki etc classifed it as hasan! I go with the first, but you will find many taking Allamah Subki's view. As Ahmed al-Ghumari mentioned "Ibn Hajr will never classify a narration as a fabrication unless its spuriousness is clear like the sun at midday". (al-Mughir)
	Quote