DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Is Salafi Interpretation of Koran in German considered a Koran

**Senasivar** · 05-25-2012, 01:17 AM

All praises are due to Allah.
Sunniforum has brothers such as Maripat who dispell wisdom and guidance ( I don't want to destroy our respected brother by showering praise upon him).

When I first converted to Islam, I was gifted a Quran with Yusuf Ali translation and commentary. I later went to the library and checked out Quran which were from Ahmadiya, as well as mere translations from various nonMuslims which can be found at the local book store. I read through several of these and compared them.

Who is to say that the Salafi translation and commentary is so abhorrent that it misguides?
If you haven't read it, why would you discourage nonMuslims from reading it?

Are my brothers aware that there are contentious political issues about Muslims in Germany, namely that the ?

Are you aware that German political powers want to divide Muslims- Sunnis vs. Salafis- and demonize Salafis, rendering them personas non grata?

Meanwhile, the German govt is neck deep in Muslim blood in Afghanistan and elsewhere, with German mercenaries functioning in Iraq and Africa and Central Asia.

Well if you were gifted with so much insight, can you answer my question?

In case you forgot, my question was: can a book without any classic Arabic whatsoever be considered a valid and authentic Koran? If not, does a book which is similar to a Koran require the same respect as an authentic Koran?

If you know so much about the situation in Germany regarding Muslims and Salafis, can you explain to me why Muslim councils in Germany distance themselves from Salafis? Why are Salafis considered violent, when all they did is knife some policemen last week or 2 weeks ago? Why is it that Salafis denounce democracy, living in a democratic state? Why would any group require the host country to abandon their legal system and the constitution to accommodate the guests?

I consider your

far right political powers do NOT like that Muslims have not assimilated to their liking a gross misrepresentation of the situation - but maybe you can clarify how it is that in Germany the far right runs the National Security forces and the police and National Intelligence?

Since 1994, the German Bundeswehr has lost about 100 troops in deployments abroad, out of which 53 German soldiers and 3 policemen died in Afghanistan, where they are deployed by ISAF. Yeah, Germans are a brutal and bloody nation, sending their mercenaries everywhere to kill innocent Muslims. It seems you are more into spreading primitive propaganda than answering a simple question.

05-25-2012, 01:17 AM	#23
Senasivar Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 431 Senior Member	All praises are due to Allah. Sunniforum has brothers such as Maripat who dispell wisdom and guidance ( I don't want to destroy our respected brother by showering praise upon him). When I first converted to Islam, I was gifted a Quran with Yusuf Ali translation and commentary. I later went to the library and checked out Quran which were from Ahmadiya, as well as mere translations from various nonMuslims which can be found at the local book store. I read through several of these and compared them. Who is to say that the Salafi translation and commentary is so abhorrent that it misguides? If you haven't read it, why would you discourage nonMuslims from reading it? Are my brothers aware that there are contentious political issues about Muslims in Germany, namely that the ? Are you aware that German political powers want to divide Muslims- Sunnis vs. Salafis- and demonize Salafis, rendering them personas non grata? Meanwhile, the German govt is neck deep in Muslim blood in Afghanistan and elsewhere, with German mercenaries functioning in Iraq and Africa and Central Asia. Well if you were gifted with so much insight, can you answer my question? In case you forgot, my question was: can a book without any classic Arabic whatsoever be considered a valid and authentic Koran? If not, does a book which is similar to a Koran require the same respect as an authentic Koran? If you know so much about the situation in Germany regarding Muslims and Salafis, can you explain to me why Muslim councils in Germany distance themselves from Salafis? Why are Salafis considered violent, when all they did is knife some policemen last week or 2 weeks ago? Why is it that Salafis denounce democracy, living in a democratic state? Why would any group require the host country to abandon their legal system and the constitution to accommodate the guests? I consider your far right political powers do NOT like that Muslims have not assimilated to their liking a gross misrepresentation of the situation - but maybe you can clarify how it is that in Germany the far right runs the National Security forces and the police and National Intelligence? Since 1994, the German Bundeswehr has lost about 100 troops in deployments abroad, out of which 53 German soldiers and 3 policemen died in Afghanistan, where they are deployed by ISAF. Yeah, Germans are a brutal and bloody nation, sending their mercenaries everywhere to kill innocent Muslims. It seems you are more into spreading primitive propaganda than answering a simple question.
	Quote