DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Under the Shade of Sharia- Somalia

**EntectCelpelm** · 07-02-2012, 08:51 AM

This is not true at all. There are plenty of authorities within each madhab that recognised it. Somalis follow the shafi madhab. You cant impose Ibn Taymiyyas narrow interpretation on them.

Al Qaeda are good propogandists from day one. When a more wholesome view of the situation is seen yyou would see a different picture. Sure there might be some law and order improvements. So are there law and order improvements with all autocrats and tyrants too. But they all crumble when the bubble burst. The longer they continue with their najdi tradition the more backlash they will face and end up like their Wahhabi leaders of the first saudi state hanged and disperesed when the Pasha of Egypt came to help them.

Name those authorities. In the Shafi madhab, it is the opinion of Imam Nawwawi, Imam Ibn Hajar and others that building on braves in a public place is haraam and in a private place, it is makruh so what Shabaab have done is fine according to the madhab of Imam Shafi.

Don't let your hatred of Salafi's blind you to the fact that they have done good in Somalia

07-02-2012, 08:51 AM	#8
EntectCelpelm Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 436 Senior Member	This is not true at all. There are plenty of authorities within each madhab that recognised it. Somalis follow the shafi madhab. You cant impose Ibn Taymiyyas narrow interpretation on them. Al Qaeda are good propogandists from day one. When a more wholesome view of the situation is seen yyou would see a different picture. Sure there might be some law and order improvements. So are there law and order improvements with all autocrats and tyrants too. But they all crumble when the bubble burst. The longer they continue with their najdi tradition the more backlash they will face and end up like their Wahhabi leaders of the first saudi state hanged and disperesed when the Pasha of Egypt came to help them. Name those authorities. In the Shafi madhab, it is the opinion of Imam Nawwawi, Imam Ibn Hajar and others that building on braves in a public place is haraam and in a private place, it is makruh so what Shabaab have done is fine according to the madhab of Imam Shafi. Don't let your hatred of Salafi's blind you to the fact that they have done good in Somalia
	Quote