DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Deoband promotes a "rigid" view of the madhab?

**Beerinkol** · 07-01-2012, 11:54 AM

Salam
Fifth: I had said it many times: I do not endorse the modernist approach of jumping and cherry-picking from the madhhabs, nor I endorse the "www.weekopinioninthemadhhab4everybody.com" attitude. But I don't like deobandic rigidity nor puritanism (by the way, both go together). I consider them sicknesses of the heart that need sufi treatment.

would people agree and say this isnt correct and deoband has produced many sufi scholars aswell

To be honest has any Deobandi forced you to do anything in your entire life ??

If the approach is rigid, the times require it perhaps, as holding on to your Deen is like holding on to hot coals. ?

They would rather be rigid in advice, knowing no one follows advice to the extreme letter, so that at least we will be nearer to benefit and further from doubt ?

Werent all the main Deobandi Ulema sufis ?

07-01-2012, 11:54 AM	#27
Beerinkol Join Date Dec 2006 Posts 5,268 Senior Member	Salam Fifth: I had said it many times: I do not endorse the modernist approach of jumping and cherry-picking from the madhhabs, nor I endorse the "www.weekopinioninthemadhhab4everybody.com" attitude. But I don't like deobandic rigidity nor puritanism (by the way, both go together). I consider them sicknesses of the heart that need sufi treatment. would people agree and say this isnt correct and deoband has produced many sufi scholars aswell To be honest has any Deobandi forced you to do anything in your entire life ?? If the approach is rigid, the times require it perhaps, as holding on to your Deen is like holding on to hot coals. ? They would rather be rigid in advice, knowing no one follows advice to the extreme letter, so that at least we will be nearer to benefit and further from doubt ? Werent all the main Deobandi Ulema sufis ?
	Quote