DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**HBPujWBe** · 06-29-2012, 12:47 AM

No honestly Turkey will do a better job organizing Hajj for the Muslim Ummah. They should divert the Hajj administration to the Turkish republic.

Concerning all your narrations, I will filter through all of them and read them carefully and I am sure you can search for many scholars who support rebellion of such and such a ruler. Can Muslims rebel against the ruler? AS I said your question has no meaning. Every social setting now or historically will be different and thus the question is too broad to be answered directly. And I have given you example where millions of Muslim rebeled against their rulers in the Arab spring. I am sure you are would have been one of the passive ideologues against the overthrow of Gaddafi, Sadam, Ben Ali, Saleh and the other lot from the way I read your posts. None openly rebelled against ISlam. The people who rebelled against their leadership thought they are deviantMuslims. Every ruler will be seen by some of its populace as deviants, oppressors or tyrants and thus justify their overthrow.

Other general information
http://harunyahya.com/en/works/14773...man_model_come

06-29-2012, 12:47 AM	#16
HBPujWBe Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 442 Senior Member	No honestly Turkey will do a better job organizing Hajj for the Muslim Ummah. They should divert the Hajj administration to the Turkish republic. Concerning all your narrations, I will filter through all of them and read them carefully and I am sure you can search for many scholars who support rebellion of such and such a ruler. Can Muslims rebel against the ruler? AS I said your question has no meaning. Every social setting now or historically will be different and thus the question is too broad to be answered directly. And I have given you example where millions of Muslim rebeled against their rulers in the Arab spring. I am sure you are would have been one of the passive ideologues against the overthrow of Gaddafi, Sadam, Ben Ali, Saleh and the other lot from the way I read your posts. None openly rebelled against ISlam. The people who rebelled against their leadership thought they are deviantMuslims. Every ruler will be seen by some of its populace as deviants, oppressors or tyrants and thus justify their overthrow. Other general information http://harunyahya.com/en/works/14773...man_model_come
	Quote