Brother you have given me your ijtihad, so you are a "ghair muqalid" then who gives your own daleel rather than quoting ulama? Why cant you provide me with kibaar ulema who have encouraged spreading teh faults of the saudi government? We have a clear hadeeth from the prophet SAW prohibbitting spreading the faults of rulers so if you want to go down teh road of us debating with daleel we can go there inshAllah but you are a hanafi so I had assumed you would be following hanafi ulema? I'm not going to read the article because all it is doing is criticising saudi faults, I already know its not a perfect country, and teh same goes for all muslim lands, but some patience and understanding is needed to differentiate between when criticism is necessary and when it isnt As this is a deobandi dominated forum I would request to know what the deobandi ulema have said inshAllah