DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - First Chinese Aircraft Carrier

**Rabbahpuptiopp** · 05-21-2007, 03:25 PM

Originally posted by Patroklos
I think our approach is is more tactically sound, but like I said your approach is still cool

Only actual combat can answer the question which approach is the best.

EDITED:

I don't claim our aproach is better. Afterall you have much more experience with a naval aviation. But this happens sometimes - Brits invented first tanks, but Germans had their own vision of panzer forces, which combat proved to be more effective. Brits made the first Dreadnought, but your Iowa class (which was a symbiosis of a battleship and a battlecruiser) became a perfection of a battleship evolution. Your aproach has won, though they had more experience (probably experience is not a proper word here, they had more time for experimenting).

05-21-2007, 03:25 PM	#30
Rabbahpuptiopp Join Date Nov 2005 Posts 462 Senior Member	Originally posted by Patroklos I think our approach is is more tactically sound, but like I said your approach is still cool Only actual combat can answer the question which approach is the best. EDITED: I don't claim our aproach is better. Afterall you have much more experience with a naval aviation. But this happens sometimes - Brits invented first tanks, but Germans had their own vision of panzer forces, which combat proved to be more effective. Brits made the first Dreadnought, but your Iowa class (which was a symbiosis of a battleship and a battlecruiser) became a perfection of a battleship evolution. Your aproach has won, though they had more experience (probably experience is not a proper word here, they had more time for experimenting).
	Quote