[qd0vhq4f]

Dear Solomon,

Mr. Querida started this thread to find the etymology of English words.

Your comment on Latin language is simply childish.

If any sanskrit words are there as roots of English mention it here. Other 'dubious' (as you always say in your passages) statements can be avoided here and put it on 'Tamil is elder to Sanskrit' Thread for healthy discussion.

Liguistic research is the best solution to find out world history. It accumulates archeology,inscriptions,literature and all forms of history research. That is why world scholars follow linguistics.

Tamil was natural language and the coining of words done naturally and not as archestrated way. Some of the new words are produced in accordance with the roots of yesteryears to solve the present purpose that too after Indian independance. This include Political and scientific terms.

Regarding my root words You made comment about 'Computer'.
It really look funny and readers also notify on that.

"Thoonkupavanai Ezhuppalaam- Aanaal Thoonkupavanai Pola Nadippavanai Ezhuppa Mudiyuma ?"

I have already revealed quoting several sources about the root words. This is enough. If you want to refute my views give your proofs since you call all our proofs 'dubious' (refelects your dubious nature)

However here I give my views in reply to your views.

Paraalumantram and Naadaalumantram have same meaning.

Para is root for 'Paar'. Para,parappu, paravai(Kadal). Parravai(Bird), Paar(ulakam) all refers to 'area' as a core and lot of 'kilavikal' same meaning words are there in tamil vocubulary.

Naadu - also means 'paravu' - 'Alai'(roam).'Naft' - an english word came from this root and this was revealed by me in the thread 'Some tamil words in world languages column'.

Ancient 'Enperaayam' & 'Kuzhu' were called 'Aalumantram'. Aalvinai, Aatchi are from root 'Aal'.

Hence the above words are much fittable. Sanskrit 'Lok shaba' & Rajya shaba have same meaning. Lok-lokam-from ulagam.

Raj-Raja- from arasa. Rather, 'makkal avai' & mel avai' also more fittable.

Your 'Makkal prathnithuva sabhai' can be understandable by tamil people only by the word Makkal. If you remove that nobody will understand.

Your forefathers did the same kind of 'myth' in 'Unarchi Pravakam' type of words / phrases.

Your forefather 'Sathyamuthy' time 'Maha Janankalae. Mahanupavarkalae' type was beautifully replaced by 'Periyorkalae and Thaaimarkalae' made you angry and talk about such things as you put it in your passage.

Computer- I give the roots. Compute means calculate.

Latin - Con-putare

Latin existed during 200 B.C. Historically there was connection between Tamil 'Musiri' port and Meditarannian sea countries.

Is there any 'Kilavikal'(same meaning words) in latin from the same root ? No.

Come to tamil. Compare 'Kaanpathu'- means 'parpathu', 'Arivathu'
'Kanakkiduvathu'

'Kan' is the root which specifies 'eye'.

'Kanakku' is from this root. 'Kaniththal' is from this root. We have finished comparing 'kilavikal'.

Hence we claim it is tamil root.

It requires some logic and reasoning and that followed by linguistics. Mr. Solomon I don't want to sum up about your logic and reasoning.

Whether 'drunkards' or 'Poets' the assembling of persons is called 'Kalzakam' and this gives the same meaning. Not different meaning.

One word may have slightly differ in meaning depending upon situations. But the core meaning is the same. We should have some deep thinking into that. Not like Mr.Soloman's " Nunipul Mayara maathiri".

I give one English word to solve this purpose.

Take 'conceive'- it means think as well as Pregnancy.

First instance the meaning seems to be different. But if we try to go deeply we find 'Product' is the common meaning.

When you think you produce something.

When you conceive you produce something.

f.s.gandhi