[prehighaltitudesjj]

Peyton Manning? Joe Montana? Bret Favre? Johnny U? John Elway? Who's your number 1(or top 5 or top 10)

[Arkadiyas]

manning
montana
marino
elway
unitas

[Tactattcahhaw]

1. Joe Montana

[BebopVT]

1. P. Manning
2. J. Unitas
3. J. Elway
4. D. Marino
5. W. Moon

[GSgCGxsF]

1. P. Manning
2. J. Unitas
3. J. Elway
4. D. Marino
5. W. Moon

Warren Moon? Really

[nursopoutaras]

Warren Moon? Really

I looked at his resume as a whole . . . not just his time in the NFL.

[Edqpdnuu]

I looked at his resume as a whole . . . not just his time in the NFL.

Still, better then Joe Montana. Better then Steve Young? Better then Otto Graham? Bart Starr? Tom Brady? I don't know if I would have Moon in my top 15.

[AdvertisingPo]

In no particular order, but Otto is #1.
Otto Graham
Johnny U
Favre
Montana
Marino
P. Manning
Bart Starr

This is like trying to decide who the top 5 hottest broads are. Everyone's opinions differ.

[UBJ3kvP1]

Montana
Manning
Graham
Unitas
Young

[bloriMal]

Otto
Bart

everybody else

[mikelangr]

Montana
Manning
Graham
Unitas
Elway

Didn't kno Canadians watched football ...

[CreativeSuiteDown]

1. Peyton
2. Montana
3. Marino
4. Graham
5. Simms (yeah I said it)
6. Elway
7. Young
8. Favre
9. Unitas
10. Starr

[Petrushkaukrop]

1. Peyton
2. Montana
3. Marino
4. Graham
5. Simms (yeah I said it)
6. Elway
7. Young
8. Favre
9. Unitas
10. Starr

Ernie Simms plays linebacker.

[ceagsoosy]

Ernie Simms plays linebacker.

Phil Simms guid', Phil Simms.

[Pete789]

1. Montana
2. Manning (with a bullet)
3. Unitas
4. Elway
5. Marino

I was torn about putting Manning first, but I won't be if he tears the NO defense a new butthole. I think that Jets game was one of the best games a QB ever had. Austin Collie? Pierre Garcon? Please...I think I could have a big game with him throwing to me. The Jets pass defense was systematically shutting everybody down, but they had no answers for Manning.

[Dyslermergerb]

1. Peyton
2. Montana
3. Marino
4. Graham
5. Simms (yeah I said it)
6. Elway
7. Young
8. Favre
9. Unitas
10. Starr

Oh. This is supposed to be a biased list?

1. Mcnabb
2. Cunningham
3. Jaworski

[doksSirmAdods]

I would have to say Montana and Manning are tied as #1 for me. I'm sure if I had watched before those guys I'd have a different answer.

[Kneedycrype]

Unitas, Baugh, Montana, Elway, Manning

maybe not in that order

[bellson]

as much as i hate favre anybody that doesn't have him in their top five is full of shit

[Poothevokprot]

as much as i hate favre anybody that doesn't have him in their top five is full of shit

I'd say a valid argument can be made for him anywhere from 1-10