[HedgeYourBets]

Atleast Danush is somewhat honest, down to earth, and attempting some stuff. Simbu, OTOH, delivers nothing, talks too much, both performance and BO is missing. Ennamo Screen Presence, athu ithunnu solraanga. Ennatha! how long can one try to survie in this heavy competition, just with Screen Presence?!?

[doctorzlo]

Both looked terrible in mass movie action sequences but Simbu improved a lot in Silambattam only to lose in Osthi. For Osthi, I would blame Dharani.
It is like blaming Dhanush for Sullan while the director should have understood how bad he is for that role.

sullaan time dhanush'kum osthi time simbu'kum comparision podringalae selva...
chinnavayasula edukkura choices'kum oralavu vevaram vandhadhukkapram nadandhukkradhukkum vitthiyaasam irukkilliyaa?

[NeroASERCH]

Appo 7 hit mattum kodutha thaan naalaya cinema vaa :P

hit'a vidunga..
flop/average padangal'layum konjam nambikkai varra maadhiri sila scenes perform pannirukkanumla..

[tgs]

neenga oru vandila engine'ae illa... theatrela thitraanganu sonningalae...
andha vandikku evlo support irukkunu dhaan andha link kuduthen...

[Lillie_Steins]

neenga oru vandila engine'ae illa... theatrela thitraanganu sonningalae...
andha vandikku evlo support irukkunu dhaan andha link kuduthen...

Thani maram thoppagaadhu...

[Fegasderty]

sullaan time dhanush'kum osthi time simbu'kum comparision podringalae selva...
chinnavayasula edukkura choices'kum oralavu vevaram vandhadhukkapram nadandhukkradhukkum vitthiyaasam irukkilliyaa?

I was referring to Director's failure while you are talking about actor's film selection and performance.
Anyway, even if you feel Sullan was during his young age, films like Padikkathavan are as bad as Osthi. I have seen both.

[9mm_fan]

Atleast Danush is somewhat honest, down to earth, and attempting some stuff. Simbu, OTOH, delivers nothing, talks too much, both performance and BO is missing. Ennamo Screen Presence, athu ithunnu solraanga. Ennatha! how long can one try to survie in this heavy competition, just with Screen Presence?!?

...............

[MannoFr]

hit'a vidunga..
flop/average padangal'layum konjam nambikkai varra maadhiri sila scenes perform pannirukkanumla..

Again, my reply was for the *naalaya cinema* comment only. He used Simbu and I am saying Dhanush is at the same level. We are not talking about relative hits/flop/average to judge naalaya cinema.

[Peptobismol]

I was referring to Director's failure while you are talking about actor's film selection and performance.
Anyway, even if you feel Sullan was during his young age, films like Padikkathavan are as bad as Osthi. I have seen both.

Bad movies are ok selva.....but actors can still manage to perform decently...

But simbu... Eppa paru korangu settaiyum konangi thanamum panitu irukan...

[Raj_Copi_Jin]

Bad movies are ok selva.....but actors can still manage to perform decently...
But simbu... Eppa paru korangu settaiyum konangi thanamum panitu irukan...

I disagree Saai.. Unless you hate Simbu *blindly* you wouldn't pass a sweeping statement like that. If you are a normal fan, you will be able to appreciate some of his good performances and agree that he is not what you described all the time .

Also, I don't see any difference between Padikkathavan Dhanush & Osthi Simbu

[Beerinkol]

Danush has unidimensional talent .. he is average otherwise

[Ifroham4]

Again, my reply was for the *naalaya cinema* comment only. He used Simbu and I am saying Dhanush is at the same level. We are not talking about relative hits/flop/average to judge naalaya cinema.

Ethula same level?? Oh, In that pic, they r sitting in similar Chair no? Yes yes, same level thaan

[S.T.D.]

I was referring to Director's failure while you are talking about actor's film selection and performance.
Anyway, even if you feel Sullan was during his young age, films like Padikkathavan are as bad as Osthi. I have seen both.

agree...
maappillai, hari movie(per nyabagam varala) are all crap...

[softy54534]

Ethula same level?? Oh, In that pic, they r sitting in similar Chair no? Yes yes, same level thaan

Thevayillatha post. You know what I meant. Chair ellam neenga measure panni paarunga.

[Peptobismol]

agree...
maappillai, hari movie(per nyabagam varala) are all crap...

Hari movie was Venghai. Athula Kanja karuppu comedy. namma censor board

[Ifroham4]

Again, my reply was for the *naalaya cinema* comment only. He used Simbu and I am saying Dhanush is at the same level. We are not talking about relative hits/flop/average to judge naalaya cinema.

naan enna sonen?
did i say we need to judge based on hits/flops...
i only spoke about the performing scenes in the flop movies, to judge naalaya cinema...

[Paul Bunyan]

disgusting is the word... aayi.

[Big A]

naan enna sonen?
did i say we need to judge based on hits/flops...
i only spoke about the performing scenes in the flop movies, to judge naalaya cinema...

oh got it Sorry. I don't just use that to judge naalaya cinema

[brraverishhh]

IMHO, they are at same level ONLY there. That apart, Danush is surely Meters ahead(if not miles) of Simbu. And even after 10 years, Simbu is gonna remain the same. He will sustain, at max. I don't see any sign of he going towards doing interesting stuff, be it commercial or class stuff.

For past some time., Situation is such that Even Jeyam Ravi can easily bounce simbu in BO. And guess what, i don't think he will even feel exceeding Simbu at BO as an achievement.

[Lillie_Steins]

Ajith fans will like Simbhu more, for obvious reasons..