[Alkanyadela]

Vettel had more points in the WDC, or should it have stayed with Webber?

Wonder if anyone can make a decision without the benefit of hindsight!

[tsamprasxx]

Should have stayed with Webber. Unless it was mathematical impossible (or highly improbable) for Webber to be WDC.

[ycMC0PLg]

my answer to a similar question...

Let me just ask the two of you this question:"If the situation was reversed, and Horner wanted to give Mark Webber the undamaged wing from Vettel's car, do you think that Mark Webber would have accepted Vettel's wing?"

If we are talking next race, based on the photo, he might take it and shove it up vettel's butt...

Based on reports from Friday after practice, neither driver wanted it....and it is not clear why it broke, so MArk might have thought he was getting the shaft from Horner and said, no, but he would not be saying because of kindness to Vettel or a sense of fair play

.

If I were Vettel, I would have said no....why take the chance of another bust

Reality is that most likely neither driver had a choice...the team does the cars, and the drivers drive. Period.

The better question is like the one posed by the FA crash in practice at Monaco, why did ferrari not take massa's car and give it to FA to qualify????

What would red bull do??

If you ask the driver without a car to take it, NO DRIVER IS GOING TO SAY NO, I would rather go smoke a cigarette and watch, not Mark and not Vettel.....which is why it should always be a bossman decision, not a driver's choice

what would red bull do?? well, I don't know.....

Vettel had more points in the WDC, or should it have stayed with Webber?

Wonder if anyone can make a decision without the benefit of hindsight!

No, and given the small difference if any, (based on qing times, which would assume everything else was absolutely the same, which it probably was not), it seems the issue from Webber is one of prinicple rather than substance of the wing actually amking any difference...Indeed, stuck with the new wing, webber might have even been slower...so who is to say??

Reminds me of children who always want what the other child has....notwithstanding what they got, might actually be better...

[Nmoitmzr]

Do we actually need 7 threads discussing 'Not bad for a number two, Did Vettel deserve the wing, Webbers half of the garage bla bla bla'.... Its getting tedious now.

The original thread started by Markabilly is sufficient to cover the whole sorry saga IMO..

[wbeachcomber]

No henners. Everytime a little bit of news surfaces we NEED another thread. Ditto when someone has a new opinion.

[VonErmad4]

Do we actually need 7 threads discussing 'Not bad for a number two, Did Vettel deserve the wing, Webbers half of the garage bla bla bla'.... Its getting tedious now.

The original thread started by Markabilly is sufficient to cover the whole sorry saga IMO..

No henners. Everytime a little bit of news surfaces we NEED another thread. Ditto when someone has a new opinion.

[wbeachcomber]

Henners and Ioan agree....... Scary stuff

[VonErmad4]

The question is another one, IMO:

Why didn't RBR have enough spares available?

[VonErmad4]

Henners and Ioan agree....... Scary stuff

Must be the heat, it's something like 42 degrees right now here.

[wbeachcomber]

Ioan, can we have another thread about why RB didn't have more than 2 wings.

[VonErmad4]

Ioan, can we have another thread about why RB didn't have more than 2 wings.

No.
I think pino will thank us for not doing it.

[Alkanyadela]

All I wanted was just a poll and nothing else. Some people will want to put their 2 cents and can't be bothered to read pages and pages of tittle tattle.

[VonErmad4]

All I wanted was just a poll and nothing else. Some people will want to put their 2 cents and can't be bothered to read pages and pages of tittle tattle.

Don't be upset. I even voted in your pole!

[Alkanyadela]

I'm not upset!

I'm upset that Daniel feels upset because my MO was for a poll - first a foremost.

If it makes Daniel feel more happy then ask Pino to disable the reply function for this thread.

[wbeachcomber]

I don't think you did anything wrong wedge, polls always deserve a thread of their own it's the 3 or 4 threads on the same topic that annoy people.

P.s I'm upset that you're upset that I'm upset

[johobuo]

Vettel had more points in the WDC, or should it have stayed with Webber?

Wonder if anyone can make a decision without the benefit of hindsight!

If there was only 1 wing this weekend it should have gone to Vettel.

There were 2 wings. Vettel's failed. Tough luck.

Physically removing the wing off Webber's car and handing it to Vettel was the problem.

[wbeachcomber]

If there was only 1 wing this weekend it should have gone to Vettel.

There were 2 wings. Vettel's failed. Tough luck.

Physically removing the wing off Webber's car and handing it to Vettel was the problem.

Are you guys still bitching about this? Webber won. Perhaps even won because he didn't have the other wing. Perhaps because of the anger....

What he needs to do now is build a bridge and get over it lest he start racing his team mate or trying to hinder vettel's championship rather than driving his own races.

What happened before qualifying wasn't nice and perhaps wasn't fair but it's in the past now. Especially now that he won the race.

[Savviioor]

No, Red Bull showed how pathetic they are.

[furious1]

Red Bull Gives you wings but it should have let Webber keep it.

[artofeyyy]

No, no, no no, no!