I did this a long time ago over on @forumz with Tori and it was fun, so I thought we'd try it with the Lady. If it doesn't go over well, I won't continue.
Definitely 1, because the color of that skirt is brilliant. She also showcases it well with a simple top, and the hair accessory pulls it together. Atta girl.
I've always loved the outfit in the first picture. Like Jake said, the color and make of the skirt is great, and it's stunning in combination with her skin tone and hair color.