[HartOvara]

So far I never managed to watch an episode of it for more than five minutes. Looks like the poor man's version of nBSG to me (style-wise, story-wise I have no idea since I never watched it long enough to get a clue what it's really about).

[SetSnonejog]

Good thus far. The daily survival routine has thus far been interesting, along with the, well, standard SG go to planet X, encounter threat, get rid of threat. Also, Lt. James' boobs.

[lorryuncori]

I'm auditioning for it next week. So I hope people keep tuning in

I'm also a fan of the show, and I don't really watch either of the other ones. I prefer serial instead of episodic television.

[UKkoXJvF]

Thanks!



Something tells me she'd be absolute crap in battle...

[kavaTeexy]

Young is no O'Neill.

Rush is as good as Carter or Mc Cay, but he is evil.

Eli is ok but no Daniel Jackson. Chloe is weak.

There is no Tilk. Not even a Ronin or Kayla. No aliens in fact which is too bad. Scott or Greer are ok but they don't give something different.

Johansen is a joke compared to other Stargate doctors.

The problem with this cast is that all characters are too grey and some are redundant. No strong female roles either.

[Haremporblape]

Young is no O'Neill.

Rush is as good as Carter or Mc Cay, but he is evil.

Eli is ok but no Daniel Jackson. Chloe is weak.

There is no Tilk. Not even a Ronin or Kayla. No aliens in fact which is too bad. Scott or Greer are ok but they don't give something different.

Johansen is a joke compared to other Stargate doctors.

The problem with this cast is that all characters are too grey and some are redundant. No strong female roles either.

Eli is a bit of a joke too. He's portrayed like a teen ager but he's supposed to be 25. past time to man-up boy!

Young is also a little bit on the evil side too. Maybe they meant for him to be a leader thrown into a tough almost no-win situation like Admiral Adama, but he doesn't come across as the epic hero like Adama.

I think they need to try a few episodes without Young - they should have extended the mutiny across several episodes.

[xLQLRcXh]

so after alot of sucking its starting to get descent. biggest probem right now seem to be the writers want to tell a epic story, and the studio wants a episode by episode typ of show. and of course it feels halfassed.
i dont really care in what direction they go just pick one damn it.

so who else is following this show?

It has been o.k. so far. Rush and Young are interesting characters. I agree though that the writers seem reluctant to extend story lines across multiple episodes. That hurts the show.

[Mqcawkzd]

I've read quite the opposite. SGU's main problem is the hiatus it had, during which Spartacus and Caprica have swept the floor.

Worse is the state of Flashforward and V. The studio execs that decided to put them in the freezer for so many months are criminally inept. A new show needs a steady full season run to establish itself.

[PRengin]

Seriusly is no one commenting the boobies? Eh, she's kind of blah otherwise

[Poreponko]

I was judging by the one picture. Admittedly, she's much more appealing naked.

[botagozzz]

Yeah, she's not a ten, but to call her "blah" is absurd.

[pepBarihepe]

I dislike the original and Atlantis. This one has a plot that carries through each episode, much better special effects and writing, and MUCH much better acting (except for Chloe). The Time episode is really good TV.

Although I gather you've never seen this show. Please, feel free to continue judging

[Siliespiriulk]

The whole Stargate universe is just awful.


I liked the movie. Kurt Russell...

[vosteglog]

if you like the movie and dislike the show your just retarded.


I rest my case.

[Fdhwzctl]

Your a smart guy. Figure it out on you're own.

[UlceskLialels]

[Kiariitf]

I can't remember the last time I ever pissed off a wookie.

[8jIDXQ80]

MrFun, I must say your new avatar disturbs me.

[palantownia]

I can't even tell if it's interracial. It's more the fact that they're from the 1970s and apparently very, very shiny.

[RjkVwPcV]

if you like the movie and dislike the show your just retarded.

Actually, that's usually the case. Most fans of the movie absolutely HATED the original show. Mostly due to the cheese factor.