[gernica]

What you think is really worth squat.

You seem to have a very constrained definition of what music is.

Do you also call yourself a music lover by any chance ?

And reading replies in this thread, it's not just you.

You're really going to defend the crap that tinomen posted?

I probably have the most eclectic music taste of anyone I know, but I can't find any redeeming parts of that.

[CIAFreeAgent]

This is one of the worst threads in a while.

You have no one to blame for it but yourself.

[nuveem7070]

You're really going to defend the crap that tinomen posted?

Yes, I am.

I probably have the most eclectic music taste of anyone I know, but I can't find any redeeming parts of that.

I don't really think you have a wide musical taste if you can't accept that.

Listen to a part of this

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cO1VVONqL4U

What do you think of that ?

[gernica]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cO1VVONqL4U

What do you think of that ?

It's nice. I wouldn't choose to listen to it very often, but it's very musical.

How does it have anything to do with the Fisher Price My First Guitar being played in Tinoman's video?

[nuveem7070]

It's nice. I wouldn't choose to listen to it very often, but it's very musical.

How does it have anything to do with the Fisher Price My First Guitar being played in Tinoman's video?

That's the thing, music, doesn't mean it has to sound "musical" as long as long as there is expression.

The song Tinomen posted has the same qualities, it just sounds different. As in, it's still music.

[CIAFreeAgent]

I'm guessing by "eclectic" he really means whatever is popular at the moment.

[gernica]

That's the thing, music, doesn't mean it has to sound "musical" as long as long as there is expression.

The song Tinomen posted has the same qualities, it just sounds different. As in, it's still music.

You're arguing for the sake of it now. Lets not get into the semantics of what actually makes music, the point being argued was whether or not it sounds any good. It doesn't.

[nuveem7070]

You're arguing for the sake of it now. Lets not get into the semantics of what actually makes music, the point being argued was whether or not it sounds any good. It doesn't.

I thought the point that was being argued was if it's music or not.

Well, it is.

If it good or not, that another story but I wouldn't trust your opinion since you are of the idea that it's not even music.

--- Post Update ---

I'm guessing by "eclectic" he really means whatever is popular at the moment.

Nah, he means, whatever genre he thinks is acceptable as music.

[gernica]

Nah, he means, whatever genre he thinks is acceptable as music.

This ridiculous, judgemental twaddle right here is exactly why people roll their eyes when you start professing to know a great deal about anything.

How would you possibly know what my reaction to any kind of music would be?

Saying that, agreeing with Tinoman is never going to help your cause.

--- Post Update ---

I'm guessing by "eclectic" he really means whatever is popular at the moment.

I dream of the day when you aren't the stupidest man on the planet. I guess until frogs start knitting there is no danger of that though.

[nuveem7070]

How would you possibly know what my reaction to any kind of music would be?

Well, you dismissed the song Tinomen posted without giving it another thought, let alone another listen.

Here's another song from the same artist.

[CIAFreeAgent]

Nah, he means, whatever genre he thinks is acceptable as music.

I like how nobody picked up on the relevance of the lyrics to the op, that sense of entitled warring aggression.

He should look up "no wave" and "noise rock", it's a specific movement against traditional musical structures, it's more about the "texture" of the sound.

This is relevant lyrically to the op too, and it's made by the same person.



Here she comes dressed in white
Her mouth is filled with flames
Her skin is black, her fingers trace
The diamonds in her veins

Here she comes down from the sun
To wash this country clean
Comes down for us, down from the dust
To murder what remains

Here she comes now dressed in red
To heal this ruined race
I know somewhere, where there's a god
He's lying at her feet

And we'll walk freely through the mountains and the trees
And we'll breathe deep again where the air is pure and clean
And we will drink freely from the milk of our revenge
And we will break down the prison gates that keep you in

So please show no pity as we come up from the ground
And please remember as you kill us and cut us down
That time will not wash clean the bloody face of history
And someone will breathe here again and they will hate you for what you leave

Here's another song from the same artist.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u4AFkuGm2Wk

great song btw.

[gernica]

Well, you dismissed the song Tinomen posted without giving it another thought, let alone another listen.

This is more stupid than the amount that crashed the Greek economy.

How many times do you think I need to listen to something to know if I like it? More to the point, how many times have you shot your mouth off over things you have spent no time considering? A million?