[Ervins Dervish]

Reminds me one of the popular urdu proverb

jis thali me khata hai usi me ched karta hai saala

This is not urdu proverb, this is hindi proverb

[Ervins Dervish]

I would have them all imprisoned until they became Hanafis :P ...not that i have anything against other Madhabs but their attack on Hanafiya is the most severe, Hence the punishment. Make them wear shalwar Kameez, or whatever they wanna wear saying Proud to be a Hanafi, and make sure they pray like Hanafis, and then make them give small bayans in gatherings about Hanafi Madhab and its Dalail. That would be one punishment :P

There is one more thing i have noticed, one will not find Nur on their faces, i dont know if its just me, but i find it hard to see any light on their faces, like the ones you find on Ulama, I saw Habib Ali Al Jafri, SubhanAllah, his face emits light literally. Yvonne Ridley met an Alim in prison and she said his face emitted light, and some tableeghis have this as well, ofcourse Mujahideen have it. But Alhe Hadeeth and Shia, not a chance, well not that i have seen atleast

Allah knows Best

Dear Sufi Taliban,

Who else you will imprison to forcefully convert them to HANAFEES...Islam does not teach this, Allah says There is no compulsion in religion. La Ikra Fiddeen.

[DghtRdc]

There is one more thing i have noticed, one will not find Nur on their faces, i dont know if its just me, but i find it hard to see any light on their faces, like the ones you find on Ulama, I saw Habib Ali Al Jafri, SubhanAllah, his face emits light literally. Yvonne Ridley met an Alim in prison and she said his face emitted light, and some tableeghis have this as well, ofcourse Mujahideen have it. But Alhe Hadeeth and Shia, not a chance, well not that i have seen atleast

i guess that means Imam Shawkani, Abu Dawud Adhahiri never had nur on their faces either?

one of the most ridiculous things i've ever heard. some people really need to know when to stop typing and keep their thoughts to themselves.

[DghtRdc]

And besides what's wrong with salafis going through hanafi books only to refute them?

it proves that they have brains and principles which they are following in fiqh. if they make it personal and bash the hanafi imams or mock thems ure then there's a problem or if they stuff down everyone's throat..but otherwise what's wrong with them going through a book refuting it's opinions and strengthening their own??

During dawra hadith do not the teachers refute the opinions of the schools that are not their own and strengthen the opinion of their own school int heir analysis of the different ahadith on a given topic? and this is done to strengthen the conviction of the students in their own madhab.

if A shafi is going through dawra hadith under a hanafi teacher he may find that very little effort is given to defend the shafi opinions rather all effort is put into refuting them and strengthening the hanafi opinions at least that's what Shaykh Taha Karan said in one of his speeches about his last year in deoband.

[CindyLavender]

And besides what's wrong with salafis going through hanafi books only to refute them?

it proves that they have brains and principles which they are following in fiqh. if they make it personal and bash the hanafi imams or mock thems ure then there's a problem or if they stuff down everyone's throat..but otherwise what's wrong with them going through a book refuting it's opinions and strengthening their own??

During dawra hadith do not the teachers refute the opinions of the schools that are not their own and strengthen the opinion of their own school int heir analysis of the different ahadith on a given topic? and this is done to strengthen the conviction of the students in their own madhab.

if A shafi is going through dawra hadith under a hanafi teacher he may find that very little effort is given to defend the shafi opinions rather all effort is put into refuting them and strengthening the hanafi opinions at least that's what Shaykh Taha Karan said in one of his speeches about his last year in deoband.

It's a problem because salafis (ahl hadeeth) from the sub continent at least, do things like this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jdsQM...eature=related

[infelconi]

i guess that means Imam Shawkani, Abu Dawud Adhahiri never had nur on their faces either?

one of the most ridiculous things i've ever heard. some people really need to know when to stop typing and keep their thoughts to themselves.

+1.