[samanthalueus]

Maybe you misunderstood what I was trying to say. Im not interested in changing your position. You asked a lot of questions and you said that you had an open mind. One of the questions was about al-Qurtubis qiyas. You said that it didn't make any sense (or something similar) You got an answer that showed that the qiyas was valid. After that you didn't want to continue the discussion. If you don't want to discuss thats fine with me, but it's a little bit strange that your honest quest for truth died out after that short discussion don't you think?

There have been a lot of people on this forum that have "none" as madhab and they claim to have an open mind and wants to discuss the evidence. As soon as the evidence doesn't point in their direction (i.e. to the salafi position) their open mind is closed. After a short while they disappear from the forum. I honestly hope you don't belong to them.

You are wrong on several accounts regarding me in your quote. however i dont feel the need to justify myself. you mentioned al-qurtubis qiyas. your explanation didnt satisfy me so i said lets agree to disagree. how does that make me a salafi?or that i dont have an open mind?and frankly speaking what exactly gives you the right to judge me according to the 'none' next to my madhab may i ask?
i respect your opinion but i disagree with it.and thats that

[Virosponna]

This is what you wrote:
but i am quite astounded as to how placing of the branches is analogous to the Prophet (PBUH) asking us to recite the Quran over graves? Now that you know that the apparent meaning of the hadith doesn't have any du'a in it we should agree that there is nothing to be astounded about, i.e there is nothing strange about al-Qurtubis qiyas, rahimahu Allah.

You are right I shouldn't judge you. Im sorry.

[samanthalueus]

This is what you wrote:

Now that you know that the apparent meaning of the hadith doesn't have any du'a in it we should agree that there is nothing to be astounded about, i.e there is nothing strange about al-Qurtubis qiyas, rahimahu Allah.

You are right I shouldn't judge you. Im sorry.

its all right. and no i dont find the Qiyas very convincing. and i never said there wasnt any dua on it. lets agree to disagree

[Hamucevasiop]

Salam aleikum

There where many questions in your post. Maybe we can discuss them one by one.



I think, and Allah knows best, that the analogy is based on the following:
1 A living person is doing an action that benefits the dead
2 This action involves the establishment of dhikr

If dhikr made by a plant benefits the dead, then the reading of the Quran (the best dhikr) will also benefit the dead.

Br Abbe,
Can you please answer this
http://www.sunniforum.com/forum/show...ion&highlight=

[opheteman]

Forum contains the issues that are occurred in all over the world we can discussed here about nay virus any destruction etc. Likewise is ukessays can made more new forums like that contains online discussions as well?