[mealiusarses]

Asalaamu alaykum

I just saw this: http://english.hizbuttahrir.org/inde...274-the-sahaba

I question just came to my mind. Using Quran and Sunnah how can we refute this claim? It's not something something I know a lot about but someone from HT told me that amir muawiah is not a sahabi!! But isnt amir muawiyah a sahabi according to their own definition?

[Nubtoubrem]

Asalaamu alaykum

I just saw this: http://english.hizbuttahrir.org/inde...274-the-sahaba

I question just came to my mind. Using Quran and Sunnah how can we refute this claim? It's not something something I know a lot about but someone from HT told me that amir muawiah is not a sahabi!! But isnt amir muawiyah a sahabi according to their own definition?

I am interested to know more about Hazrat Muawiah (RAD). Is there any authentic biography about him ?

[Dwemadayday]

According to HT, sayyiduna Mu'awiya (radiya Allahu Ta'ala 'anhu) was not a Sahabi. I think they have the same view of sayyiduna Abu Sufyan and sayyiduna 'Amr ibn al-'As (radiya Allahu Ta'ala 'anhuma). Their reasons for this deviant belief is going against the Khalifa (sayyiduna 'Ali, radiya Allahu 'anhu wa karrama wajhah).

La hawla wa la quwwata illa billah...

Thick books could be written on the deviances of Hizb ut-Tahrir.

[Tauntenue]

Salam Aleykum,

He is a Sahabi according to all definitions and if I may add that the dust on his shoes is worth thousands of Hizb-ul-Tahrir members.

[Apparpsmose]

Read wht Shekh Abdul Qadir Jilani has written in Ghunia..
U can have the book written by Zafar Iqbal sahab i guess named AMeer-e-Muawiya ra gumrah kun ghalat fehmion ka azala
Ism-e-Muawiyah ra
Ameer-e-Muawaiya ra aur tareekhi haqaiq by Hazrat Mufti Taqi sb dbh!!

[jimmy28]

Walaikum Salam,

Thanks for telling us about this group. This means they are saying that Muawiyah (ra) was not a believer. These people from this group are not even scholars of Islam and they speak from their stomachs. All Ale-Sonnat agree that he(ra) was a Sahabi.