[ahagotyou]

Asslamualaikum,

Can some confirm if we have substantial evidence to believe that Hinda r.z destroyed the grave of the Mother of prophet s.a.w ?

[ahagotyou]

bump

[Affiltavajefe]

no she did not.

there is a narration I dont know how authentic it is but shaikh shady sulayman mention this in his seerah lectures that before the battle of uhud, hinda mentioned destroying the grave of the mother of the prophet pbuh but abu sufyan ra stopped her stating that this practice could become the norm between opposing parties in wars/disputes

[ahagotyou]

no she did not.

there is a narration I dont know how authentic it is but shaikh shady sulayman mention this in his seerah lectures that before the battle of uhud, hinda mentioned destroying the grave of the mother of the prophet pbuh but abu sufyan ra stopped her stating that this practice could become the norm between opposing parties in wars/disputes

So, it is through authentic / rekliable source that Hinda r.z did wish and decide [hand the intension] to destroy the Grave of the mohter of the prophet s.a.w ?

[Teprophopay]

So, it is through authentic / rekliable source that Hinda r.z did wish and decide [hand the intension] to destroy the Grave of the mohter of the prophet s.a.w ?

mohtashims brother the whole family have similar stories

[Nicihntm]

If this is an academic discussion, then its ok.

But have this in mind:

-Hind (ra) ate Hamza (ra) liver after He was martyred.
-Umar(ra) was on the way to assassinate Rasoolullah before He embraced Islam.
-Abu Sufyan (ra) was against Islam and fought numerous wars against Rasoolullah .
etc etc etc.....


A lot of Sahabah did a lot of things against Islam while they were mushriks before accepting Islam.
But it doesn't matter.
La ilaaha illAllah Muhammadu rasoolullah, changes everything.

[ahagotyou]

It's purely an acedemic discussion and no finger pointing.

I just wanted to confirm if this was true and reliable that she wanted to destroy the prophet's s.a.w mother's grave.

On the contrary I understand that the prophet s.a.w himself constructed or repaired his mother's grave.

[Affiltavajefe]

It's purely an acedemic discussion and no finger pointing.

I just wanted to confirm if this was true and reliable that she wanted to destroy the prophet's s.a.w mother's grave.

On the contrary I understand that the prophet s.a.w himself constructed or repaired his mother's grave.

If I was not clear before - i would just like to say that it was a suggestion to damage the grave - not that she wanted to do it, or she planned to do it - it was before uhud so she was not a muslim at this point as others have pointed out

[ppaelkos]

It's purely an acedemic discussion and no finger pointing.

I just wanted to confirm if this was true and reliable that she wanted to destroy the prophet's s.a.w mother's grave.

On the contrary I understand that the prophet s.a.w himself constructed or repaired his mother's grave.

any details at to the construction or repairs made to the grave?