so what you saying is that the first hole should have been played the same way no matter it used to be a par5. So they should have played for bogie. When the usga changes a par 5 into a par 4 it's not to give the players a mental nudge. It's to make the course harder. It requires two solid shots instead of three to achieve the new par. Play three shots and one putting for par is not the way the hole and it's difficulty we're designed. The reward for one putting is birdie, on this hole.