DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**dianakroshXX** · 12-28-2011, 09:24 PM

What was Habib Umar's response to the question?

It seems there is a difference of approach between Habib Ali and the other Haba'ib we have seen (e.g. Habib Umar and Habib Kazim). For example his visit to Shaykh Nazim Haqqani. Who is Habib Ali's murshid?

Another question, I have heard that they sometimes use music in their zikr in later stages (like the flute). Do you know if this is true or false? What is their stance on music and zikr?

How is there a difference between Habib 'Ali and Habib 'Umar and Habib Kazim? As for the visit to Shaykh Haqqani, Habib Kazim also visitted him with his father, and so did Habib Abu Bakr, an elder Habib. Habib 'Ali's murshid was Habib 'Abdul Qadir as-Saqqaf, then Habib 'Umar. Any other examples of this so-called difference in approach?

There is no 'later stages'. It's nothing to do with tariqah: the fuqaha' of hadramawt permitted the flute along with the duff, following Imam ar-Rafi'i of the Shafi'i madh-hab. And a shafi'i can tell you ar-Rafi'is place in the madh-hab, only second to an-Nawawi.

12-28-2011, 09:24 PM	#8
dianakroshXX Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 468 Senior Member	What was Habib Umar's response to the question? It seems there is a difference of approach between Habib Ali and the other Haba'ib we have seen (e.g. Habib Umar and Habib Kazim). For example his visit to Shaykh Nazim Haqqani. Who is Habib Ali's murshid? Another question, I have heard that they sometimes use music in their zikr in later stages (like the flute). Do you know if this is true or false? What is their stance on music and zikr? How is there a difference between Habib 'Ali and Habib 'Umar and Habib Kazim? As for the visit to Shaykh Haqqani, Habib Kazim also visitted him with his father, and so did Habib Abu Bakr, an elder Habib. Habib 'Ali's murshid was Habib 'Abdul Qadir as-Saqqaf, then Habib 'Umar. Any other examples of this so-called difference in approach? There is no 'later stages'. It's nothing to do with tariqah: the fuqaha' of hadramawt permitted the flute along with the duff, following Imam ar-Rafi'i of the Shafi'i madh-hab. And a shafi'i can tell you ar-Rafi'is place in the madh-hab, only second to an-Nawawi.
	Quote