DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**Abofedrorobox** · 12-29-2011, 02:24 PM

What was Habib Umar's response to the question?

It seems there is a difference of approach between Habib Ali and the other Haba'ib we have seen (e.g. Habib Umar and Habib Kazim). For example his visit to Shaykh Nazim Haqqani. Who is Habib Ali's murshid?

Another question, I have heard that they sometimes use music in their zikr in later stages (like the flute). Do you know if this is true or false? What is their stance on music and zikr?

habib ali is a mureed of habib umar no doubt, the picture of bayat at the hands of sh nizaam could have been for barakah only. yes they use flutes in hadhra saqaf, the flute used is permissable according one view in the shafi' madhab. the daff is halaal & to put the steel on the side of the daff is permissable too.

12-29-2011, 02:24 PM	#17
Abofedrorobox Join Date Dec 2005 Posts 465 Senior Member	What was Habib Umar's response to the question? It seems there is a difference of approach between Habib Ali and the other Haba'ib we have seen (e.g. Habib Umar and Habib Kazim). For example his visit to Shaykh Nazim Haqqani. Who is Habib Ali's murshid? Another question, I have heard that they sometimes use music in their zikr in later stages (like the flute). Do you know if this is true or false? What is their stance on music and zikr? habib ali is a mureed of habib umar no doubt, the picture of bayat at the hands of sh nizaam could have been for barakah only. yes they use flutes in hadhra saqaf, the flute used is permissable according one view in the shafi' madhab. the daff is halaal & to put the steel on the side of the daff is permissable too.
	Quote