[AdvertisingPo]

Assalamu alaykum

وه ايک اعتراض اتهاتے هيں که جو قرآن کى آيتيں تم لوگ بطور دليل کے پيش کرتے هو وه آيتيں عموم پر دلالت کرتى هيں يا مخصوص پر The OP has asked "they (gair muqallideen) argue that the ayah quoted as reference (for taqeed) by us, do they refer to specific or general (criteria)?"

Smoking is prohibited by

"The Ruling of Smoking" by Muhammad bin Ibraaheem (r)

"The Ruling of Smoking" by `Abdur-Rahman Bin Naasir as-Sa`di (r).

"The Ruling of Smoking" by `Abdul-`Aziz Bin 'Abdullaah Bin Baaz.

"The Ruling of Smoking" by Muhammad Bin Salih al-'Uthaymin.

Hukm ul-lslami fit-Tadkhin by Muhammad Jamil Zinu.

Hukm ud-Dini fil-Lihyati wat-Tadkhin by 'Ali Hasan al-Halabi.

The ayah quoted by these scholars are:

"Do not kill yourselves, Allah is indeed merciful to you"

"Do not cast yourselves, with your own hands, into destruction"

Now ask the gair muaqallideen whether these ayah are "specific" or "general"?