DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**xtrslots** · 10-16-2011, 09:39 PM

If we're honest, sidi Rifai, wouldn't you agree that Zaydi fiqh has less to do with Imam Zayd than it has to do with Imam al-Hadi? The only link to Imam Zayd, perhaps, is his Musnad.

What is your opinion with regards to the authenticity of the Musnad al-Imam Zayd? Many have done Jarh on 'Amr b. Khalid al-Waisiti, the one who narrates all the ahadith in it. Of course, the Zaydis say that this was due to Nasibi-bias etc

The Zaydis are famous with the statement "li kulli mujtahidin nasib", hence Imam al-Hadi most likely made his own ijtihadaat.

How do they determine ijma' of Ahl al-Bayt? Many Ahl al-Bayt differed with each other on many issues, so how do you establish that they all agree on a certain issue? What are some of these masaa'il?

was-salam

10-16-2011, 09:39 PM	#8
xtrslots Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 509 Senior Member	If we're honest, sidi Rifai, wouldn't you agree that Zaydi fiqh has less to do with Imam Zayd than it has to do with Imam al-Hadi? The only link to Imam Zayd, perhaps, is his Musnad. What is your opinion with regards to the authenticity of the Musnad al-Imam Zayd? Many have done Jarh on 'Amr b. Khalid al-Waisiti, the one who narrates all the ahadith in it. Of course, the Zaydis say that this was due to Nasibi-bias etc The Zaydis are famous with the statement "li kulli mujtahidin nasib", hence Imam al-Hadi most likely made his own ijtihadaat. How do they determine ijma' of Ahl al-Bayt? Many Ahl al-Bayt differed with each other on many issues, so how do you establish that they all agree on a certain issue? What are some of these masaa'il? was-salam
	Quote