DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Istinjaa, Tahaarah, and western/english style toilets.

**dwestemesse** · 09-08-2010, 07:23 PM

I just had a couple questions from reading bro Antivirus's post in connection to bro Abu Zaid's post. Maybe I understood wrong but here goes:

Isn't relieving oneself while making ghusl (or in the place of ghusl)makrooh? Or if someone stood and relieved himself during ghusl, wouldn't that be like double makrooh.

It's makrooh if the water collects there and it doesn't drain away. Usually, in normal showers, the water drains away so it should be fine. If the water does not drain properly, then it would be makrooh to take a shower in the place of urination.

It's makrooh to urinate standing up unless there is a valid reason to stand up.

09-08-2010, 07:23 PM	#17
dwestemesse Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 478 Senior Member	I just had a couple questions from reading bro Antivirus's post in connection to bro Abu Zaid's post. Maybe I understood wrong but here goes: Isn't relieving oneself while making ghusl (or in the place of ghusl)makrooh? Or if someone stood and relieved himself during ghusl, wouldn't that be like double makrooh. It's makrooh if the water collects there and it doesn't drain away. Usually, in normal showers, the water drains away so it should be fine. If the water does not drain properly, then it would be makrooh to take a shower in the place of urination. It's makrooh to urinate standing up unless there is a valid reason to stand up.
	Quote